当前位置: X-MOL 学术Environ. Evid. › 论文详情
Our official English website, www.x-mol.net, welcomes your feedback! (Note: you will need to create a separate account there.)
Evidence on the social, economic, and environmental impact of interventions that facilitate bamboo industry development for sustainable livelihoods: a systematic map protocol
Environmental Evidence ( IF 3.3 ) Pub Date : 2022-10-20 , DOI: 10.1186/s13750-022-00286-8
Lucy Binfield , Tamara L. Britton , Chunping Dai , John Innes

Bamboo has been identified as a potential instrument for socioeconomic development due to its fast growth, perceived environmental benefits, promising material properties, myriad applications, and relative underdevelopment as a global industrial product. Many projects and interventions have been carried out that aim to utilize bamboo’s social and environmental potential in development. However, critical evaluations that demonstrate this effect using real-world evidence and outcomes are rare, and existing case studies have not been collated and analyzed in a systematic way. The proposed systematic map aims to summarize and evaluate evidence on the social, economic, and environmental impact of bamboo industry development initiatives on beneficiary communities and ecosystems, and to identify priority areas for future funding and research. In the proposed systematic map, we will collect and thematically categorize evidence on the social, environmental, and economic impact of bamboo development implementations, identifying themes, research gaps, and critical success factors. Literature discussing this type of intervention is published by researchers, organizations, and governments in academic journals, institutional reports, and program evaluations describing various socio-economic and environmental outcomes, impacts and metrics for success. Search sources for this systematic map therefore include bibliographic databases, institutional websites, web-based search engines, and expert consultation. Targeted search strings will be used to identify relevant texts in a two-step review process comprising an abstract and a full-text screening process. Sources describing interventions with a primary aim of bamboo industry development for social benefit that concluded between 1990 and 2021 will be sought. Metadata coded from these texts will be reviewed, categorized, and checked by two reviewers. Reviewers will be checked for consistency on batches of 30 articles using the Kappa interrater reliability test with a goal of a Kappa coefficient of 0.9. Metadata will be coded into different categories including outcomes and impacts using NVivo. Results of both quantitative and qualitative data analysis will be summarized in a searchable online database. Themes will be synthesized and explored in a narrative review and using simple logic models demonstrating theories of change for eligible case studies.

中文翻译:

关于促进竹产业发展以促进可持续生计的干预措施的社会、经济和环境影响的证据:系统地图协议

由于竹子的快速增长、可感知的环境效益、有前景的材料特性、无数的应用以及作为全球工业产品的相对欠发达,竹子已被确定为社会经济发展的潜在工具。已经开展了许多旨在利用竹子在发展中的社会和环境潜力的项目和干预措施。然而,使用现实世界的证据和结果证明这种影响的批判性评估很少见,并且现有的案例研究尚未以系统的方式进行整理和分析。拟议的系统地图旨在总结和评估竹产业发展举措对受益社区和生态系统的社会、经济和环境影响的证据,并确定未来资助和研究的优先领域。在拟议的系统地图中,我们将收集有关竹子开发实施的社会、环境和经济影响的证据并按主题分类,确定主题、研究差距和关键成功因素。研究人员、组织和政府在学术期刊、机构报告和计划评估中发表了讨论此类干预的文献,描述了各种社会经济和环境结果、影响和成功指标。因此,该系统地图的搜索来源包括书目数据库、机构网站、基于网络的搜索引擎和专家咨询。有针对性的搜索字符串将用于在包括摘要和全文筛选过程的两步审查过程中识别相关文本。将寻找描述干预措施的来源,其主要目的是为了社会利益而发展竹产业,这些干预措施在 1990 年至 2021 年间结束。从这些文本编码的元数据将由两名审阅者审阅、分类和检查。将使用 Kappa 评价者间信度测试来检查审稿人对 30 篇文章批次的一致性,目标是 Kappa 系数为 0.9。元数据将使用 NVivo 编码成不同的类别,包括结果和影响。定量和定性数据分析的结果将汇总在可搜索的在线数据库中。主题将在叙述性评论中进行综合和探索,并使用简单的逻辑模型展示符合条件的案例研究的变化理论。
更新日期:2022-10-20
down
wechat
bug