We propose an approach to assess, and thus, update the technology roadmapping process. Building on extant literature, we define the ideal roadmapping process and suggest an integrated framework to guide its improvement from three perspectives: process maturity, system elements, and contextual validity. To verify its effectiveness, we applied the proposed approach to roadmapping conducted by a Korean government agency responsible for technology planning at the national level. We found that the assessment guidelines could help an organization systematically identify its roadmap process’s strengths and weaknesses to build an approach toward process enhancement.

中文翻译：

---

从多个角度评估技术路线图过程的综合框架：行业层面的案例

我们提出了一种评估并因此更新技术路线图流程的方法。在现有文献的基础上，我们定义了理想的路线图流程，并提出了一个综合框架来从三个角度指导其改进：流程成熟度、系统元素和上下文有效性。为了验证其有效性，我们将拟议的方法应用于由负责国家级技术规划的韩国政府机构进行的路线图绘制。我们发现，评估指南可以帮助组织系统地识别其路线图流程的优势和劣势，以构建流程改进方法。