Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry ( IF 2.662 ) Pub Date : 2023-09-03 , DOI: 10.1016/j.jbtep.2023.101909 Jessica Uhl 1 , Steffen Eberhardt 1 , Brian Schwartz 1 , Eshkol Rafaeli 2 , Wolfgang Lutz 1
Background and objectives
Imagery-based techniques have become a promising means in the treatment of test anxiety (TA). Although previous studies have demonstrated the effectiveness of imagery-based treatment, not all clients seem to benefit from it. The present study compares clients' pre- as well as post-treatment emotion dynamics between responders and non-responders. Furthermore, it examines treatment-related changes in emotion dynamics in both subgroups.
Methods
The results are based on 44 clients suffering from TA who underwent a six-session imagery-based treatment and include Ecological Momentary Assessment (EMA). Emotions were assessed with the Profile of Mood States four times a day over the course of two weeks before and after the treatment. Temporal networks were computed to index emotion dynamics.
Results
Pre-treatment emotion dynamics differed between responders and non-responders. Similarly, post-treatment emotion dynamics differed as well between both groups. Some changes were also observed between pre-treatment and post-treatment networks: for responders, fatigue no longer predicted anger, and depression predicted itself; for non-responders, calmness predicted fatigue, anger, depression, contentment, and anxiety. In addition, fatigue no longer predicted itself and anxiety predicted vigor.
Limitations
The investigation is marked by several limitations: a liberal inclusion threshold of at least a 50% response to EMA prompts, and a relatively homogenous sample.
Conclusion
These results provide first evidence for the idea that emotion dynamics may be associated with response to treatment for TA. Furthermore, effective imagery-based treatments may be tied to changes within these dynamics.
中文翻译:
测试焦虑患者在意象治疗前后的情绪动态
背景和目标
基于图像的技术已成为治疗考试焦虑(TA)的一种有前途的手段。尽管之前的研究已经证明了基于意象的治疗的有效性,但似乎并非所有客户都能从中受益。本研究比较了有反应者和无反应者治疗前和治疗后的情绪动态。此外,它还检查了两个亚组中与治疗相关的情绪动态变化。
方法
结果基于 44 名患有 TA 的客户,他们接受了六次基于图像的治疗,包括生态瞬时评估 (EMA)。在治疗前后的两周内,每天使用情绪状态概况评估四次情绪。计算时间网络来索引情绪动态。
结果
治疗前有反应者和无反应者之间的情绪动态有所不同。同样,两组治疗后的情绪动态也不同。在治疗前和治疗后网络之间也观察到了一些变化:对于反应者来说,疲劳不再预示着愤怒,而抑郁则预示着自身;对于无反应的人来说,平静预示着疲劳、愤怒、抑郁、满足和焦虑。此外,疲劳不再预示着自身,焦虑预示着活力。
局限性
该调查有几个局限性:对 EMA 提示的至少 50% 响应的自由纳入阈值,以及相对同质的样本。
结论
这些结果为情绪动态可能与 TA 治疗反应相关这一观点提供了第一个证据。此外,有效的基于图像的治疗可能与这些动态的变化有关。