Nontargets: Understanding the Apathy Towards the Israeli Security Agency’s COVID-19 Surveillance
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
This article tackles one of the latest—but nonetheless baffling—displays of public apathy towards surveillance: that of much of the Israeli public towards the decision to recruit the Israeli Security Agency (Shin Bet) to do COVID-19 contact tracing during the ongoing coronavirus pandemic. The case of a secretive state agency being authorized to do surveillance on its citizens for a strictly non-security-related matter seems to realize many of the dangers that surveillance/privacy scholars warn about with regards to surveillance expansion, function creep, and the creation of a surveillance state. I contribute to existing literature about apathy towards surveillance and the privacy paradox by offering the term “nontargets” as an explanation. This term suggests that, alongside social groups that are likely to be targeted by a given surveillance application, there are certain recognizable nontargets that most likely will not bear the brunt of the surveillance, at least not in the short- and medium-term, and thus do not fear it. In the case at hand, which is examined using a qualitative context-bound study, I suggest that Jewish-Israelis are such a nontarget group with regards to this novel Shin Bet surveillance, which explains a significant part of their apathy towards it.
Article Details
Surveillance & Society uses a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0 License.
- The author. The author licenses the article to the Surveillance Studies Network (SSN) for inclusion in Surveillance & Society (S&S), right of first publication. The copyright to the article remains with the author and any subsequent commercial reuse must be agreed by both parties.
- Non-commercial Users. SSN authorises all persons to use material published in S&S in any manner that is not primarily intended for or directed to commerical advantage or private monetary compensation, also provided that it is not modified and retains all attribution notices.
- Commercial Users. SSN retains the right to benefit from commerical reuse, in each specific case subject to the agreement of the author, and payment to SSN of a standard per-page fee (set by a vote of the Network and Editorial Board) by the Commercial User.
- Surveillance & Society supports open access archives and the free distribution of the results of academic work. Authors are encouraged to place copies of the final published version of their article in their university and / or other open access archives. We only ask that you make sure to include a link to the original published version on the Surveillance & Society website.
References
Acquisti, Alessandro, Laura Brandimarte, and George F. Loewenstein. 2015. Privacy and Human Behavior in the Age of Information. Science 347 (6221): 509–514.
Adalah. 2020. Adalah's Initial Analysis of the Shin Bet (“Shabak”) Coronavirus Cellphone Surveillance Case. Haifa, IL: Adalah.
Appelberg, Shelly. 2020. The Head of the Ministry of Health in a Closed Meeting: Want to Open Shopping Malls? Track Visitors. [In Hebrew.] TheMarker, April 20. https://www.themarker.com/coronavirus/1.8793390 [accessed May 26, 2020].
Arutz Sheva. 2020. The Shin Bet Contact-Tracing Falsely Alerted of Exposure Between People in Phone Contact. [In Hebrew.] Arutz Sheva, November 24. https://www.inn.co.il/news/458314 [accessed December 14, 2020].
Aschkenasy, Bini. 2020. In Europe They Forbid Security Agencies Surveillance on Citizens—And What about Israel? [In Hebrew.] TheMarker, October 8. https://www.themarker.com/law/.premium-1.9220799 [accessed October 9, 2020].
Association for Civil Rights in Israel, The. 2018. Detaining Social Activists in Airports. https://www.english.acri.org.il/post/___33 [accessed June 18, 2020].
Avriel, Eytan. 2020. The Shin Bet's Location System Doesn't Do the Job. This is What Will. [In Hebrew.] TheMarker, June 24. https://www.themarker.com/podcasts/PODCAST-1.8945074 [accessed June 28, 2020].
Azulay, Moran, and Adir Yanko. 2020. A Heated Debate in the Knesset: “The Epidemiological Investigations are a Hundred Times More Obtrusive Than the Shin Bet Tracking.” [In Hebrew.] Ynet, June 24. https://www.ynet.co.il/articles/0,7340,L-5753513,00.html [accessed June 25, 2020].
Baek, Young Min. 2014. Solving the Privacy Paradox: A Counter-Argument Experimental Approach. Computers in Human Behavior 38: 33–42.
Barnea, Avner. 2020. The Shin Bet Coronavirus Surveillance. [In Hebrew.] Paper presented at the Online Surveillance in the Age of Coronavirus and Beyond, June 15.
Barnes, Susan B. 2006. A Privacy Paradox: Social Networking in the United States. First Monday 11 (9): https://doi.org/10.5210/fm.v11i9.1394.
Benziman, Uzi, and Atallah Mansour. 1992. Subtenants: Israeli Arabs, Their Status, and the Policy Towards Them. [In Hebrew.] Jerusalem, IL: Keter Publishing House.
Best, Kirsty. 2010. Living in the Control Society: Surveillance, Users and Digital Screen Technologies. International Journal of Cultural Studies 13 (1): 5–24.
Bigo, Didier. 2004. Globalized-In-Security: The Field and the Ban-Opticon. Traces: A Multilengual Journal of Cultural Theory 4: https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203926765-7.
Binyamin, Idan. 2020. Due to a Delay Caused by the Ministry of Health: The Shin Bet Surveillance Might Come Back. [In Hebrew.] Shakuf, June 21. https://shkifut.info/tag/%D7%9E%D7%A9%D7%A8%D7%93-%D7%94%D7%91%D7%A8%D7%99%D7%90%D7%95%D7%AA/ [accessed July 20, 2020].
Birnhack, Michael D. Forthcoming. Privacy in Crisis: Constitutional Engineering and Privacy Engineering. [In Hebrew.] Law and Government in Israel.
Bohbot, Hagar. 2020a. “You Have Been Exposed to the Coronavirus”: A Malfunction in Hamagen App. [In Hebrew.] Ynet, March 28. https://www.ynet.co.il/digital/technews/article/S1GKAonLU [accessed May 26, 2020].
———. 2020b. Hamagen App Still Sends False Warnings to Users. [In Hebrew.] Ynet, April 5. https://www.ynet.co.il/digital/technews/article/SJpiMXPvL [accessed May 26, 2020].
boyd, danah, and Eszter Hargittai. 2010. Facebook Privacy Settings: Who Cares? First Monday 15 (8): https://doi.org/10.5210/fm.v15i8.3086.
Breiner, Josh, and Bar Peleg. 2020. 30 Thousand People Entered Quarantine Due to Shin Bet Coronavirus Tracking. [In Hebrew.] Haaretz, July 4. https://www.haaretz.co.il/health/corona/.premium-1.8969925 [accessed July 5, 2020].
Budak, Jelena, and Edo Rajh. 2018. Citizens' Online Surveillance Concerns in Croatia. Surveillance & Society 16 (3): 347–361.
Campbell, Nancy D. 2004. Technologies of Suspicion: Coercion and Compassion in Post-Disciplinary Surveillance Regimes. Surveillance & Society 2 (1): 78–94.
Carey, Robert, and Jacquelyn Ann Burkell. 2009. A Heuristics Approach to Understanding Privacy-Protecting Behaviors in Digital Social Environments. In Lessons from the Identity Trail: Anonymity, Privacy and Identity in a Networked Society, edited by Ian Kerr, Valerie Steeves, and Carole Lucock, 65–82. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Chalklen, Charlotte, and Heather Anderson. 2017. Mothering on Facebook: Exploring the Privacy/Openness Paradox. Social Media + Society 3 (2): https://doi-org.libproxy.lib.unc.edu/10.1177%2F2056305117707187.
Chan, Janet B. L. 2008. The New Lateral Surveillance and a Culture of Suspicion. Surveillance and Governance: Crime Control and Beyond 10: 223–239.
Cohen, Sagi. 2020. Hamagen 2 App Won't Save Us as Either—And Apple and Google are to Blame. [In Hebrew.] TheMarker, June 24. https://www.themarker.com/technation/.premium-1.8944903?v=31A030BE08F430A2DF1C7516F1E911F2 [accessed June 25, 2020].
Davis, Darren W., and Brian D. Silver. 2004. Civil Liberties vs. Security: Public Opinion in the Context of the Terrorist Attacks on America. American Journal of Political Science 48 (1): 28–46.
Degani, Arnon Yehuda. 2015. The Decline and Fall of the Israeli Military Government, 1948–1966: A Case of Settler-Colonial Consolidation? Settler Colonial Studies 5 (1): 84–99.
Dolev, Daniel. 2020. In a Limited Application: The Use of Shin Bet Tracking in the Struggle Against Corona Was Ratified. [In Hebrew.] Walla, May 26. https://news.walla.co.il/item/3363103 [accessed June 2, 2020].
Duke, Shaul A. Forthcoming. The Dynamics of Imposed Transparency and Its Role in Deep Social Conflicts. In Trust and Transparency in an Age of Surveillance, edited by Paweł Laidler and Lora Anne Viola, 1–20. London: Routledge.
Earl, Jennifer. 2011. Political Repression: Iron Fists, Velvet Gloves, and Diffuse Control. Annual Review of Sociology 37: 261–284.
Eiserbuch, Dafna. 2020. A Controversial Tool. [In Hebrew.] Davar, July 1. https://www.davar1.co.il/233156/ [accessed July 5, 2020].
Fiske, John. 1998. Surveilling the City: Whiteness, the Black Man and Democratic Totalitarianism. Theory, Culture & Society 15 (2): 67–88.
Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, The. 2020. The 23rd Protocol of the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee. [In Hebrew.] Jerusalem, IL: The Knesset.
Gandy, Oscar H., Jr. 1989. The Surveillance Society: Information Technology and Bureaucratic Social Control. Journal of Communication 39 (3): 61–76.
———. 2002. Data Mining and Surveillance in the Post-9/11 Environment. Paper presented at the International Association for Media and Communication Research, Barcelona, Spain, July, 2002, 1–18. IAMCR.
———. 2011. Consumer Protection in Cyberspace. Triple C 19 (2): 175–189.
Gerber, Nina, Paul Gerber, and Melanie Volkamer. 2018. Explaining the Privacy Paradox: A Systematic Review of Literature Investigating Privacy Attitude and Behavior. Computers & Security 77: 226–261.
Goichman, Refaella. 2020a. Placement, Movement and Surprise Visits: The Full Map of Who Tracks Us Using the Coronavirus Excuse. [In Hebrew.] TheMarker, April 6. https://www.themarker.com/technation/.premium-1.8742498?v=426E8C338E34706CE3407F44573E76D6 [accessed May 26, 2020].
———. 2020b. Why is the Government Insisting the Shin Bet Be the One to Track Us? [In Hebrew.] TheMarker, June 5. https://www.themarker.com/technation/.premium-MAGAZINE-1.8896687 [accessed June 6, 2020].
———. 2020c. Tens of Meetings—And the Same Result: The State Approved the Shin Bet Tracking Again. [In Hebrew]. TheMarker, November 23. https://www.themarker.com/technation/.premium-1.9323272?lts=1607950122169 [accessed December 14, 2020].
Goichman, Refaella, and Hagai Amit. 2020. “Instead of Preventing Terrorism, the Shin Bet is Preventing Protest”: The Member of Knesset That is Sure That Nethanyahu Enlisted the Coronavirus to the Coalition. [In Hebrew.] TheMarker, June 10. https://www.themarker.com/technation/.premium-1.8908760 [accessed June 11, 2020].
Gontarz, Nir. 2020. The Assumption That It Isn't Possible to Do Epidemiological Investigations Without the Shin Bet Isn't True. [In Hebrew.] Haaretz, July 7. https://www.haaretz.co.il/magazine/.premium-1.8976594 [accessed July 8, 2020].
Haggerty, Kevin D., and Richard V. Ericson. 2000. The Surveillant Assemblage. British Journal of Sociology 51 (4): 605–622.
Handel, Ariel. 2011. Exclusionary Surveillance and Spatial Uncertainty in the Occupied Palestinian Territories. In Surveillance and Control in Israel/Palestine: Population, Territory and Power, edited by Elia T. Zureik, David Lyon, and Yasmeen Abu-Laban, 259–275. London: Routledge.
Hargittai, Eszter, and Alice E. Marwick. 2016. “What Can I Really Do?” Explaining the Privacy Paradox with Online Apathy. International Journal of Communication 10: 3737–3757.
Henman, Paul. 2004. Targeted! International Sociology 19 (2): 173–191.
———. 2005. E-Government, Targeting and Data Profiling: Policy and Ethical Issues of Differential Treatment. Journal of E-Government 2 (1): 79–98.
Heravi, Alireza, Sameera Mubarak, and Kim-Kwang Raymond Choo. 2018. Information Privacy in Online Social Networks: Uses and Gratification Perspective. Computers in Human Behavior 84: 441–459.
Hermann, Tamar, and Or Anabi. 2020. Israeli Voice Index: 76% of Israelis are Afraid of Getting Coronavirus. Jerusalem, IL: The Israel Democracy Institute.
Jabareen, Hassan. 2007. The Unlawful Engagement of the Shin Bet. [In Hebrew.] Haifa, IL: Adalah.
Jamal, Amal A. 2000. Israel's Political Regime: Ethnic Democracy and the Critique of Reality. [In Hebrew.] Israeli Sociology 2 (2): 631–646.
Kim, Mun-Cho. 2004. Surveillance Technology, Privacy and Social Control. International Sociology 19 (2): 193–213.
Klein, Naomi. 2007. The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism. New York: Metropolitan Books.
Kokolakis, Spyros. 2017. Privacy Attitudes and Privacy Behaviour: A Review of Current Research on the Privacy Paradox Phenomenon. Computers & Security 64: 122–134.
Komam, Nir. 2020. A Poll: How Much the Public Believes That the Shin Bet Contact-Tracing Support the Struggle Against the Coronavirus. [In Hebrew.] Ice., August 30. http://www.ice.co.il/research/news/article/785113 [accessed December 16, 2020].
Lee, Jin-Myong, and Jong-Youn Rha. 2016. Personalization-Privacy Paradox and Consumer Conflict with the Use of Location-Based Mobile Commerce. Computers in Human Behavior 63: 453–462.
Lentin, Ronit. 2017. Race and Surveillance in the Settler Colony: The Case of Israeli Rule Over Palestine. Palgrave Communications 3: https://doi.org/10.1057/palcomms.2017.56.
Leshem, Eitan. 2020. In Order to Avoid the Shin Bet Contact-Tracing Many Go Back to Using the “Dumb” Phones. [In Hebrew] Haaretz, July 16. https://www.haaretz.co.il/captain/.premium-1.8998539 [accessed August 6, 2020].
Linder, Ronny. 2020a. The Bizarre Story of Dr. Itamar Zilberman: “The Text Came Back Negative—But the Shin Bet Sent Everyone to Quarantine.” [In Hebrew.] TheMarker, March 22. https://www.themarker.com/news/health/1.8698612 [accessed May 26, 2020].
———. 2020b. One of the Essential Workers for the Struggle Against the Coronavirus in Israel Was Placed in Isolation Because of the Shin Bet—And Doesn't Understand Why. [In Hebrew.] TheMarker, March 24. https://www.themarker.com/news/health/1.8705463 [accessed May 26, 2020].
———. 2020c. In Secret—The Health Ministry Recently Opened the Possibility to Appeal the Shin Bet's Tracking Results. [In Hebrew] TheMarker, April 17. https://www.themarker.com/consumer/health/1.8776960 [accessed May 26, 2020].
Linder, Ronny, and Refaella Goichman. 2020. “Damn Those Shin Bet Inspections. Shout Hard in Protest from Outside Because We are Breaking Down.” [In Hebrew.] TheMarker, July 5. https://www.themarker.com/coronavirus/.premium-1.8972215 [accessed July 7, 2020].
Liss, Yonatan. 2020. About 60% of Appeals After Being Sent to Quarantine Based on the Shin Bet Contact Tracing Got an Approval to Exit It. [In Hebrew.] Haaretz, July 19. https://www.haaretz.co.il/health/corona/.premium-1.9004817 [accessed July 21, 2020].
Lukash, Alexandra. 2020. Received a Fake Message That Her Daughter is Suspected of Being Infected in Coronavirus: “We Will Quarantine Her.” [In Hebrew.] Ynet, March 20. https://www.ynet.co.il/articles/0,7340,L-5700155,00.html [accessed May 26, 2020].
Lyon, David. 2004. Globalizing Surveillance. International Sociology 19 (2): 135–149.
Marx, Gary T. 1988. Undercover: Police Surveillance in America. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Melman, Yossi. 2020. The Vulnerability of Locating Infected People: Exposure of Secret Methods and Leaks from the Ministry of Health. [In Hebrew.] Haaretz, March 19. https://www.haaretz.co.il/blogs/yossimelman/BLOG-1.8690799 [accessed May 26, 2020].
Murakami Wood, David. 2009. The “Surveillance Society.” European Journal of Criminology 6 (2): 179–194.
Murakami Wood, David, Kristie Ball, David Lyon, Clive Norris, and Charles Raab. 2006. A Report on the Surveillance Society. London: Surveillance Studies Network.
Natour, Rajaa. 2020. No Democratic Country Used Its Secret Service in Its Struggle Against the Pandemic. [In Hebrew.] Haaretz, May 13. https://www.haaretz.co.il/misc/article-print-page/MAGAZINE-1.8842363 [accessed June 2, 2020].
Nelkin, Dorothy, and Lori Andrews. 1999. DNA Identification and Surveillance Creep. Sociology of Health & Illness 21 (5): 689–706.
Norris, Clive. 2003. From Personal to Digital: CCTV, the Panopticon, and the Technological Mediation of Suspicion and Social Control. In Surveillance as Social Sorting: Privacy, Risk, and Digital Discrimination, edited by David Lyon, 249–281. London: Routledge.
Orwell, George. 1949. 1984. London: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
Pascovich, Eyal. 2015. Not Above the Law: Shin Bet's (Israel Security Agency) Democratization and Legalization Process. Journal of Intelligence History 14 (1): 54–69.
———. 2017. Shin Bet and the Challenge of Right-Wing Political Extremism in Israel. International Journal of Intelligence and CounterIntelligence 30 (2): 269–309.
Pedahzur, Ami. 2009. The Israeli Secret Services and the Struggle Against Terrorism. New York: Columbia University Press.
Pentina, Iryna, Lixuan Zhang, Hatem Bata, and Ying Chen. 2016. Exploring Privacy Paradox in Information-Sensitive Mobile App Adoption: A Cross-Cultural Comparison. Computers in Human Behavior 65: 409–419.
Public Committee Against Torture in Israel, The. 2020. Torture in Israel 2020: An Overview. [In Hebrew.] Jerusalem, IL: The Public Committee against Torture in Israel.
Romele, Alberto, Francesco Gallino, Camilla Emmenegger, and Daniele Gorgone. 2017. Panopticism is Not Enough: Social Media as Technologies of Voluntary Servitude. Surveillance & Society 15 (2): 204–221.
Rubinstein, Roy. 2020. People Who Were Sent to Quarantine are Claiming False Detection: “It’s Frustrating, Everything is Messed Up.” [In Hebrew.] Ynet, July 5. https://www.ynet.co.il/article/HJ2QQqy1P [accessed July 7, 2020].
Schwartz Altshuler, Tehilla, and Hagai Levine. 2020. Members of Israel's Government—We Told You So! [In Hebrew.] Haaretz, July 21. https://www.haaretz.co.il/opinions/.premium-1.9009695 [accessed December 24, 2020].
Shafir, Gershon, and Yoav Peled. 2002. Being Israeli: The Dynamics of Multiple Citizenship. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Sheleff, Leon. 2002. The Necessity of Defense of the Truth: On the Tortuous Deliberations about the Use of Torture. [In Hebrew.] Bar-Ilan Law Studies 17 (2): 459–493.
Smooha, Sammy. 2000. The State of Israel's Regime: A Civil Democracy, a Non-Democracy, or an Ethnic Democracy? [In Hebrew.] Israeli Sociology 2 (2): 565–623.
———. 2010. Israel Society: Like Other Societies or Exceptional Case? [In Hebrew.] Israeli Sociology 11 (2): 297–302.
Snowden, Edward. 2019. Permanent Record. London: Pan Macmillan.
Sokol, Sam. 2020. I Wasted 2 Days Holed Up in My Bedroom Thanks to Buggy Health Ministry Virus App. Times of Israel, April 27. https://www.timesofisrael.com/i-wasted-2-days-holed-up-in-my-bedroom-thanks-to-buggy-health-ministry-virus-app/ [accessed May 27, 2020].
Speak, Suzanne, and Stephen Graham. 1999. Service Not Included: Private Services Restructuring, Neighbourhoods, and Social Marginalisation. Environment and Planning A 31 (11): 1985–2001.
Starr, Amory, Luis A. Fernandez, Randall Amster, Lesley J. Wood, and Manuel J. Caro. 2008. The Impacts of State Surveillance on Political Assembly and Association: A Socio-Legal Analysis. Qualitative Sociology 31 (3): 251–270.
State Comptroller of Israel. 2000. A Summary of a Report on the Investigation System in the Israeli Security Agency (Shin Bet) for the Years 1988-1992. [In Hebrew.] Jerusalem, IL: State Comptroller of Israel.
———. 2020. A Special Interim Report on the Topic of Israel's Coping with the Corona Crisis. [In Hebrew.] Jerusalem, IL: State Comptroller of Israel.
Taddicken, Monika. 2014. The “Privacy Paradox” in the Social Web: The Impact of Privacy Concerns, Individual Characteristics, and the Perceived Social Relevance on Different Forms of Self-Disclosure. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication 19 (2): 248–273.
Yablonko, Yasmin. 2020. Not on Par with Europe's Pace: Why the Outdated Israeli Privacy Legislation Can Harm Its Economy. [In Hebrew.] Globes, July 20. https://www.globes.co.il/news/article.aspx?did=1001336550 [accessed December 24, 2020].
Yakir, Dan. 2018. No More “Administrative Mistakes”! Association for Civil Rights in Israel, August 17. https://www.english.acri.org.il/post/___24 [accessed June 18, 2020].
Yanko, Adir. 2020a. Scarce Personnel, Impassible Conditions and Faulty Training: Epidemiological Investigations are on the Brink of Collapse. [In Hebrew.] Ynet, June 30. https://www.ynet.co.il/articles/0,7340,L-5756712,00.html [accessed June 30, 2020].
———. 2020b. The Calendar Was Exposed: A Meeting of Shin Bet Representatives with the Director of the Ministry of Education about Arab Students. [In Hebrew.] Ynet, February 13. https://www.ynet.co.il/articles/0,7340,L-5676612,00.html [accessed July 23, 2020].
Yanko, Adir, Tova Zimuki, Itamar Eichner, and Gilad Morag. 2020. A Greater Number of Uninstalls Than of Installs: The “Hamagen 2” Campaign Was Stopped. [In Hebrew.] Ynet, August 9. https://www.ynet.co.il/article/SJqLkKh11D [accessed August 10, 2020].
Yasur, Beit-Or, Maytal. 2020. The Shin Bet Tracked Half of the People Contracted in the Second Wave. [In Hebrew.] Israel Hayom, September 17. https://www.israelhayom.co.il/article/802259 [accessed December 15, 2020].
Yiftachel, Oren. 1999. Ethnocracy: The Politics of Judaizing Israel/Palestine. Constellations 6 (3): 364–390.
Yuchtman-Yaar, Ephraim, and Tamar Hermann. 2016. Peace Index—December 2015. Jerusalem, IL: The Israel Democracy Institute.
Zaken, Danny. 2020. Eli Cohen: The Shin Bet Contact-Tracing Will Be Terminated by January 21. [In Hebrew.] Globes, December 16. https://www.globes.co.il/news/article.aspx?did=1001353436 [accessed December 28, 2020].
Zamir, Yitzhak. 2019. The Bus 300 Affair. [In Hebrew.] Jerusalem, IL: Israel's Ministry of Justice.
Zazim Community Action. 2020. Our Privacy is in Danger (Online Petition). [In Hebrew.] https://act.zazim.org.il/petition/stop_corona_surveillance_he [accessed July 17, 2020].