The Noise of Silent Machines: A Case Study of LinkNYC
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
In early 2016, the city of New York and the Google-backed consortium CityBridge launched LinkNYC, a communication network that enables residents and visitors to access Wi-Fi, charge their phones, and make domestic calls—all for free. The ten-feet tall kiosks scattered around the city are also equipped with screens, cameras, a tablet, speakers, and a microphone. Almost immediately after its launch, many raised concerns about LinkNYC: noise complaints concerning users listening to loud music, homeless people gathering around the kiosks, outrage regarding users watching pornography, as well as the potential threat to privacy the kiosks present. In this paper, I argue that LinkNYC functions as a neoliberal apparatus of listening and silencing in the public sphere through data collection and restrictions of usage of the kiosk in the name of accessibility. As Google’s first attempt at occupying the public space, LinkNYC reveals the aspirations for the neoliberal city. Through an ethnographic socio-technological study of LinkNYC, I engage sound studies in current discussions about surveillance. I theorize the modalities of listening in the neoliberal city and discuss competing notions of the public space in smart/responsive cities. I investigate the ideological difference between the smart city and the responsive city and trace the movement from a listening entity to a responsive one, analyzing the implications for privacy. I theorize unsilencing and its politics, discussing examples of re-appropriation of the kiosks. I conducted fieldwork by observing interactions with the kiosks and by doing interviews with citizens, homeless advocacy groups, CityBridge employees, and experts. In addition, I analyze the discourses of CityBridge, local politicians, activists, journalists, and citizens surrounding LinkNYC. This paper is at the theoretical intersection of sound studies, urban studies, science and technology studies, and surveillance studies. Through this case study, I open a theorization of the listening practices of surveillance to look at how power circulates through sound.
Article Details
Surveillance & Society uses a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0 License.
- The author. The author licenses the article to the Surveillance Studies Network (SSN) for inclusion in Surveillance & Society (S&S), right of first publication. The copyright to the article remains with the author and any subsequent commercial reuse must be agreed by both parties.
- Non-commercial Users. SSN authorises all persons to use material published in S&S in any manner that is not primarily intended for or directed to commerical advantage or private monetary compensation, also provided that it is not modified and retains all attribution notices.
- Commercial Users. SSN retains the right to benefit from commerical reuse, in each specific case subject to the agreement of the author, and payment to SSN of a standard per-page fee (set by a vote of the Network and Editorial Board) by the Commercial User.
- Surveillance & Society supports open access archives and the free distribution of the results of academic work. Authors are encouraged to place copies of the final published version of their article in their university and / or other open access archives. We only ask that you make sure to include a link to the original published version on the Surveillance & Society website.
References
Aiello, Tony. 2016. Free Wi-Fi Kiosks Prompt Concerns of Potential Misuse By Homeless New Yorkers. CBS, June 13. http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2016/06/13/free-wi-fi-kiosks/ [accessed January 13, 2021].
Amsellem, Audrey. Forthcoming. Alexa and the Making of the Neoliberal Ear. Law Text Culture 24.
Arditi, David. 2012. Disciplining the Consumer: File-Sharers under the Watchful Eye of the Music Industry. In Internet and Surveillance, edited by Christian Fuchs, Kees Boersma, Anders Albrechtslund, and Marisol Sandoval, 190–206. New York: Routledge
Bernstein, Joseph, Sarah Ryley, and Jeremy Singer-Vine. 2014. Exclusive: Hundreds of Devices Hidden Inside New York City Phone Booths. BuzzFeed News, October 6. https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/josephbernstein/exclusive-hundreds-of-devices-hidden-inside-new-york-city-ph [accessed May 14, 2021].
Beu, Brenden. 2020. The Future of Digitally Activated Cities. Presented at the Bath Digital Festival, Bath, United Kingdom, October 20–24. https://bathdigitalfestival.co.uk/events/tech:world/the-future-of-digitally-activated-cities.html.
Bijsterveld, Karin. 2008. Mechanical Sound: Technology, Culture and Public Problems of Noise in the Twentieth Century. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
———. 2010. Acoustic Cocooning: How the Car Became a Place to Unwind. The Senses and Society 5 (2): 189–211.
———. 2014. Dissecting Sound: Speaker Identification at the Stasi and Sonic Ways of Knowing. Presented at Sawyer Seminar: “Hearing Modernity,” Harvard University, Cambridge MA, March 31.
Bull, Michael, and Les Back. 2016. The Auditory Culture Reader. Routledge: London.
Burton, Justin A. 2018. They Can Hear Us: Surveillance and Race in ‘A Quiet Place’ Sounding Out!, June 18. https://soundstudiesblog.com/2018/06/18/they-can-hear-us-surveillance-and-race-in-a-quiet-place/ [accessed May 14, 2021].
CityBridge. 2014. Diff Checker: Privacy Policy. https://www.diffchecker.com/haMx1arr.
———. 2017. Privacy Policy : LinkNYC. March 17. https://www.link.nyc.
Connor, Steven. 2014. Sadistic Listening. Presented at Sawyer Seminar: “Hearing Modernity,” Harvard University, Cambridge MA.
Control Group, and Titan. 2013. Reinventing Payphones - NYC I/O: The Responsive City, video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Run-IbUzG8M [accessed January 13, 2021].
Copenhafer, David. 2018. Overhearing (in) Touch of Evil and The Conversation: From ‘Real Time’ Surveillance to Its Recording. Sound Studies 4 (1): 2–18.
Crawford, Kate. 2009. Following You: Disciplines of Listening in Social Media. Continuum 23 (4): 525–535.
———. 2012. Four Ways of Listening to an iPhone: From Sound and Network Listening to Biometric Data and Geolocative Tracking. In Studying Mobile Media: Cultural Technologies, Mobile Communication, and the iPhone, edited by Larissa Hjorth, Ingrid Richardson, and Jean Burgess, 213–239. London: Routledge.
———. 2016. Susan Crawford on The Responsive Communities Initiative. Berkman Klein Center, Harvard Law School, video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_TI3Xk7eWxg [accessed January 13, 2021].
———. 2018. Beware of Google’s Intentions. Wired. https://www.wired.com/story/sidewalk-labs-toronto-google-risks/ [accessed May 21, 2021].
Crawford, Susan, and Stephen Goldsmith. 2014. The Responsive City: Engaging Communities through Data-Smart Governance. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Dean, Benjamin. 2016. LinkNYC Spy Stations. The Eleventh HOPE, video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EBrZ_Ra5hFw&ab_channel=Channel2600 [accessed January 13, 2021].
Dockray, Sean, James Parker, and Joel Stern. 2020. Curriculum/Machine Listening. Liquid Architecture and Unsound. https://machinelistening.exposed/curriculum/ [accessed January 13, 2021].
Doctoroff, Daniel L. 2016. Reimagining Cities from the Internet Up. Medium, December 12. https://medium.com/sidewalk-talk/reimagining-cities-from-the-internet-up-5923d6be63ba [accessed May 15, 2021].
Drott, Eric A. 2018. Music as a Technology of Surveillance. Journal of the Society for American Music 12 (3): 233–267.
Eidsheim, Nina S. 2021. Dismantling the Panopticon Ear and Aural Redlining. Presented at The Twenty-Fourth Annual Graduate Students in Music Conference, CUNY Graduate Center, March 20.
Fox, Aaron A. 2013. Repatriation as Re-Animation through Reciprocity: Laura Boulton’s 1946 Iñupiaq Recordings and the Future of the Music Archive. In Cambridge History of World Music, edited by Philip V. Bohlman, 522–554. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Gaylin, Ann. 2002. Eavesdropping in the Novel from Austen to Proust. New York: Cambridge University Press.
GSAPP Students. 2017. Hacking The Urban Experience - Interactive Intervention at LinkNYC. Tumblr. http://hackingtheurbanexperience.tumblr.com/post/160452420685/interactive-intervention-at-linknyc-gsapp [accessed May 23, 2017].
Gunderson, Frank D., Robert C. Lancefield, and Bret D. Woods, eds. 2019. The Oxford Handbook of Musical Repatriation. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Harris, Mark. 2016. Inside Alphabet’s Money-Spinning, Terrorist-Foiling, Gigabit Wi-Fi Kiosks. Vox, July 1. https://www.vox.com/2016/7/1/12072122/alphabet-sidewalk-labs-city-wifi-sidewalk-kiosks [accessed January 12, 2021].
IBO. 2013. New York City Public Payphones: How Many Are Left? New York City by the Numbers, October 31. http://ibo.nyc.ny.us/cgi-park2/2013/10/new-york-city-public-payphones-how-many-are-left/ [accessed December 13, 2016].
Ingraham, Nathan. 2015. Google’s Sidewalk Labs Is Taking over the Plan to Blanket NYC with Free Wi-Fi. The Verge, June 23. https://www.theverge.com/2015/6/23/8834863/google-sidewalk-labs-linknyc-free-wifi [accessed June 1, 2021].
Intersection. 2018. Copyright Claim and Notice to Takedown Infringing Works under Provisions of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2018/2018-08-06-Intersection.md [accessed January 13, 2021].
James, Robin. 2014. Acousmatic Surveillance and Big Data. Sounding Out!, October 20. https://soundstudiesblog.com/2014/10/20/the-acousmatic-era-of-surveillance/.
Kanno-Youngs, Zolan. 2016. New York City’s Wi-Fi Plan Faces Delays, Criticism. Wall Street Journal, July 23. https://www.wsj.com/articles/new-york-citys-wi-fi-plan-faces-delays-criticism-1469234058 [accessed May 13, 2021].
Katyal, Sonia. 2005. Privacy vs. Piracy. Yale Journal of Law and Technology 7 (1): 222–346.
Kofman, Ava. 2018. Are New York’s Free LinkNYC Internet Kiosks Tracking Your Movements? The Intercept, September 8. https://theintercept.com/2018/09/08/linknyc-free-wifi-kiosks/ [accessed January 13, 2021].
LinkNYC (@LinkNYC). 2016a. #ICYMI - LinkNYC will help to bridge the digital divide in #NYC @NYCMayorsOffice #tech. Twitter, February 6. https://twitter.com/LinkNYC/status/695985833283842048 [accessed June 2, 2021].
———. 2016b. ~16% of Americans don't own a smartphone, tablet, desktop, or laptop @pewresearch LinkNYC's tablet will soon make web-access more accessible. Twitter, February 15, 12:57 p.m. https://twitter.com/LinkNYC/status/699291370356412416 [accessed June 2, 2021].
———. 2016c. our goal is to provide web access to those who need it most! the internet isn't a luxury anymore, it's a right. Twitter, May 23, 1:09 p.m. https://twitter.com/LinkNYC/status/745029256191815680 [accessed June 2, 2021].
———. 2016d. It's all about connecting the unconnected. Twitter, June 20, 1:25 p.m. https://twitter.com/LinkNYC/status/744944161510522880 [accessed June 2, 2021].
———. 2016e. #ICYMI An important talk about the value of web access for homesless #WWDNYC. Twitter, June 20, 7:03 p.m. https://twitter.com/LinkNYC/status/745029256191815680 [accessed June 2, 2021].
———. 2016f. As urban population rises, it's increasingly important that we build just and inclusive cities. Twitter, June 27, 12:27 p.m. https://twitter.com/LinkNYC/status/747466479705161732 [accessed June 2, 2021].
LinkNYC Support (@LinkNYC_Support). 2016. Links are not meant for long-term use, so we're making changes to make Links more accessible. Twitter, September 14, 11:45 a.m. https://:twitter.com/LinkNYC_Support/status/776129866135666688 [accessed June 1, 2021].
Mattern, Shannon. 2017. A City Is Not a Computer. Places Journal, February 7. https://placesjournal.org/article/a-city-is-not-a-computer/?cn-reloaded=1&cn-reloaded=1&cn-reloaded=1.
Mariko, Hirose, and Johanna Miller. 2016. Re: LinkNYC Privacy Policy, March 15. https://www.nyclu.org/sites/default/files/releases/city%20wifi%20letter.pdf [accessed January 13, 2021].
Marx, Gary T. 2008. Soul Train: The New Surveillance in Popular Music. In Lessons From the Identity Trail. edited by Kerr, V. Steeves, C. Lucock, 377–398. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
McCormick, Rich. 2016. Alphabet’s Sidewalk Labs Plans to Take Over Public Transport in Columbus, Ohio. The Verge, June 27. https://www.theverge.com/2016/6/27/12048482/alphabet-sidewalk-labs-public-transport-columbus-ohio [accessed January 12, 2021].
McDonough, Annie. 2020. DoITT Head Jessica Tisch’s Hard Line against LinkNYC Vendor. CSNY, March 4. https://www.cityandstateny.com/articles/policy/technology/doitt-head-jessica-tischs-hard-line-against-linknyc-vendor.html [accessed January 13, 2021].
McGeehan, Patrick. 2016. Free Wi-Fi Kiosks Were to Aid New Yorkers: An Unsavory Side Has Spurred a Retreat. The New York Times, September 14. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/15/nyregion/internet-browsers-to-be-disabled-on-new-yorks-free-wi-fi-kiosks.html [accessed January 13, 2021].
McGinley, Paige. 2006. Eavesdropping, Surveillance, and Sound. PAJ: A Journal of Performance and Art 28 (1): 51¬–57.
Merrill, Andrew. 2017. The Life of a Gunshot: Space, Sound and the Political Contours of Acoustic Gunshot Detection. Surveillance & Society 15 (1): 42–55.
Murakami Wood, David. 2015. Smart City, Surveillance City. Society for Computers and Law, July 1. https://www.scl.org/articles/3405-smart-city-surveillance-city [accessed June 1, 2021].
Nevill-Manning, Craig. 2016. Sidewalk Labs: Reimagining the City as a Digital Platform. Google TechTalks, video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bPu8HvD7d9U [accessed June 1, 2021].
Neville, Stephen. 2020. Eavesmining: A Critical Audit of the Amazon Echo and Alexa Conditions of Use. Surveillance & Society 18 (3): 343–356.
Nielson, Erik. 2010. “Can't C Me”: Surveillance and Rap Music. Journal of Black Studies 40 (6): 1254–1274.
Novak, David. 2015. Noise. In Keywords in Sound, edited by David Novak and Matt Sakakeeny. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
NYCLU. 2017. City Strengthens Public Wi-Fi Privacy Policy After NYCLU Raises Concerns. New York Civil Liberties Union, March 17. https://www.nyclu.org/en/news/city-strengthens-public-wi-fi-privacy-policy-after-nyclu-raises-concerns [accessed January 23, 2018].
O'Donnell, Colin (@colin_odonnell). 2016. Per the @UN, internet access is a #humanright; proud that #LinkNYC will connect #homeless & LGBT NYers http://huff.to/1kRmi58. Twitter, January 8, 7:33 p.m. https://twitter.com/colin_odonnell/status/685620285672976385 [accessed June 2, 2021].
———. 2017. Smart Cities Are Boring. Give Us Responsive Cities. TechCrunch, October 13. https://social.techcrunch.com/2017/10/14/smart-cities-are-boring-give-us-responsive-cities/ [accessed August 14, 2020].
O’Grady, Nathaniel. 2020. Automating Security Infrastructures: Practices, Imaginaries, Politics. Security Dialogue 52 (3): 231–249.
Ochoa Gautier, Ana María. 2014. Aurality: Listening and Knowledge in Nineteenth-Century Colombia. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
———. 2015. Silence. In Keywords in Sound, edited by David Novak and Matt Sakakeeny. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Offenhartz, Jake. 2018. Creepy Mister Softee Mystery Solved: Meet The Man Who Uses LinkNYC To Freak Out NYers.” Gothamist, December 13. https://gothamist.com/arts-entertainment/creepy-mister-softee-mystery-solved-meet-the-man-who-uses-linknyc-to-freak-out-nyers [accessed August 14, 2020].
Ogasawara, Midori. 2019. Mainstreaming Colonial Experiences in Surveillance Studies. Surveillance & Society 17 (5): 726–729.
Pinto, Nick. 2016. Google Is Transforming NYC’s Payphones Into a Personalized Propaganda Engine. Village Voice, July 6. http://www.villagevoice.com/news/google-is-transforming-nycs-payphones-into-a-personalized-propaganda-engine-8822938 [accessed August 14, 2020].
Prey, Robert. 2015. “Now Playing. You”: Big Data and the Production of Music Streaming Space. PhD diss., Simon Fraser University.
Radovac, Lilian. 2015. The Muted City: New York, Noise Control and the Reconfiguration of Urban Space. PhD diss., McGill University.
Rethink LinkNYC. 2020. About Us. http://rethinklink.nyc/index.html [accessed September 1, 2020].
Robinson, Dylan. 2020. Hungry Listening: Resonant Theory for Indigenous Sound Studies. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Schanzenbach, Max, and Nadav Shoked. 2018. Reclaiming Fiduciary Law for the City. Stanford Law Review 70 (2): 1–49.
Shapiro, Aaron. 2018. Design, Control, Predict: Cultural Politics In The Actually Existing Smart City. PhD diss., University of Pennsylvania.
Singer-Vine, Jeremy. 2016. Here’s Alphabet’s Pitch To “Smart”-Ify Your City. BuzzFeed News, October 7. https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/jsvine/alphabets-pitch-to-smartify-your-city [accessed February 2021].
Sterne, Jonathan. 2003. The Audible Past: Cultural Origins of Sound Reproduction. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
———. 2005. Urban Media and the Politics of Sound Space. Sound Art and Culture 9: 6–15.
———. 2015. Hearing. In Keywords in Sound, edited by David Novak and Matt Sakakeeny, 65–77. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Stoever, Jennifer Lynn. 2016. The Sonic Color Line: Race and the Cultural Politics of Listening. New York: New York University Press.
Szendy, Peter. 2017. All Ears: The Aesthetics of Espionage. New York: Fordham University Press.
Tisch, Jessica. 2020. NYCC Fiscal Year 2021 Preliminary Budget Hearing. https://councilnyc.viebit.com/player.php?hash=lXV2Ja3P9Onh [accessed September 1, 2020].
Weaver, Shaye. 2016. LinkNYC Kiosks Clogging Sidewalks With Encampments and Drug Deals: Locals. DNAinfo New York, July 11. https://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20160711/upper-east-side/linknyc-kiosks-clogging-sidewalks-with-encampments-drug-deals-locals [accessed May 13, 2021].
Zuboff, Shoshana. 2019. The Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power. New York: Public Affairs.
Zureik, Elia. 2015. Colonialism as Surveillance. In Israel’s Colonial Project in Palestine, 95–134. London: Routledge.