Abstract
The criminal legal system is a “stratifying institution” insofar as it reflects inequalities by selecting already marginalized people into the system, worsens existing inequalities via a host of criminal punishment and conditions of confinement mechanisms, and creates new inequalities through patterns of isolation for formerly incarcerated people and spillover effects for those close to them. Because it is impossible to separate mass criminalization from the patterns of inequality that precede it and ill-advised to treat inequalities created by mass criminalization as somehow separate from much longer legacies of marginalization and social exclusion, the prospects for criminal justice reform are difficult to predict. This essay suggests that criminal justice reform strategies centered on harm reduction might reasonably reduce how much criminal justice involvement worsens existing inequalities or creates new ones. Dramatically reducing inequalities in initial contacts with the system will be more difficult because that would require significant investments and improvements in other social systems. Moreover, because the criminal legal system is not a system at all, reform efforts must be multi-pronged and target all parts of the system to appreciably reduce inequality.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Agan, A. Y., Doleac, J. L., & Harvey, A. (2021). Misdemeanor Prosecution (Working Paper No. 28600). National Bureau of Economic Research.
Alexander, M. (2012). The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness. The New Press.
Apel, R. (2016). The effects of jail and prison confinement on cohabitation and marriage. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 665(1), 103–126.
Avent-Holt, D., & Tomaskovic-Devey, D. (2010). The relational basis of inequality: Generic and contingent wage distribution processes. Work and Occupations, 37(2), 162–193.
Bares, K. J., & Mowen, T. J. (2020). Examining the parole officer as a mechanism of social support during reentry from prison. Crime & Delinquency, 66(6–7), 1023–1051.
Barno, M., Martínez, D. N., & Williams, K. R. (2020). Exploring alternatives to cash bail: An evaluation of orange county’s Pretrial Assessment and Release Supervision (PARS) program. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 45(3), 363–378.
Bartos, B. J., & Kubrin, C. E. (2018). Can we downsize our prisons and jails without compromising public safety? Criminology & Public Policy, 17(3), 693–715.
Baumer, E. P. (2013). Reassessing and redirecting research on race and sentencing. Justice Quarterly, 30(2), 231–261.
Beckett, K. (1999). Making Crime Pay: Law and Order in Contemporary American Politics (Revised edition). Oxford University Press.
Beckett, K., Nyrop, K., & Pfingst, L. (2006). Race, drugs, and policing: Understanding disparities in drug delivery arrests. Criminology, 44(1), 105–137.
Bell, M. C. (2017). Police reform and the dismantling of legal estrangement. The Yale Law Journal, 126, 2054–2150.
Bell, M. C., Beckett, K., & Stuart, F. (2020). Investing in alternatives: Three logics of criminal system replacement symposium: From police reform to public safety. UC Irvine Law Review, 11(5), 1291–1326.
Ben-Moshe, L., Chapman, C., & Carey, A. (Eds.). (2014). Disability Incarcerated: Imprisonment and Disability in the United States and Canada (2014th edition). Palgrave Macmillan.
Bittner, E. (1974). Florence Nightingale in Pursuit of Willie Sutton: A Theory of the Police. In H. Jacob (Ed.), The Potential for Reform of Criminal Justice (vol. 3, pp. 11–44). SAGE Publications Ltd.
Bjornstrom, E. E. S., Kaufman, R. L., Peterson, R. D., & Slater, M. D. (2010). Race and ethnic representations of lawbreakers and victims in crime news: A national study of television coverage. Social Problems, 57(2), 269–293.
Blumstein, A. (1967). Systems analysis and the criminal justice system. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 374(1), 92–100.
Brame, R., Bushway, S., Paternoster, R., & Turner, M. G. (2014). Demographic patterns of cumulative arrest prevalence by ages 18 and 23. Crime & Delinquency, 60.
Burton, A. L., Cullen, F. T., Pickett, J. T., Burton, V. S., Jr., & Thielo, A. J. (2021). Beyond the eternal criminal record: Public support for expungement. Criminology & Public Policy, 20(1), 123–151.
Butler, L. C., Cullen, F. T., Burton, A. L., Thielo, A. J., & Burton, V. S., Jr. (2020). Redemption at a correctional turning point: Public support for rehabilitation ceremonies. Federal Probation, 84(1), 38–47.
Calathes, W. (2017). Racial capitalism and punishment philosophy and practices: What really stands in the way of prison abolition. Contemporary Justice Review, 20(4), 442–455.
Christie, N. (1986). The Ideal Victim. In E. A. Fattah (Ed.), From Crime Policy to Victim Policy: Reorienting the Justice System (pp. 17–30). Palgrave Macmillan UK.
Clair, M. (2020). Privilege and Punishment: How Race and Class Matter in Criminal Court. Princeton University Press.
Clear, T. R. (2008). The effects of high imprisonment rates on communities. Crime and Justice, 37(1), 97–132.
Cobbina, J. (2019). Hands Up, Don’t Shoot: Why the Protests in Ferguson and Baltimore Matter, and How They Changed America. NYU Press.
Cochran, J. C., & Mears, D. P. (2013). Social isolation and inmate behavior: A conceptual framework for theorizing prison visitation and guiding and assessing research. Journal of Criminal Justice, 41(4), 252–261.
Comfort, M. (2007). Punishment beyond the legal offender. Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 3(1), 271–284.
Cunneen, C., & Tauri, J. M. (2019). Indigenous peoples, criminology, and criminal justice. Annual Review of Criminology, 2(1), 359–381.
Dee, T. S., & Pyne, J. (2022). A community-response approach to mental-health and substance-abuse crises reduced crime. Science Advances, 8(eabm2106), 1–9.
Dilulio, J. (2019). The coming of the super-predators. The Weekly Standard, 1(November), 23–29.
DiPrete, T. A., & Eirich, G. M. (2006). Cumulative advantage as a mechanism for inequality: A review of theoretical and empirical developments. Annual Review of Sociology, 32(1), 271–297.
DiPrete, T. A., & Fox-Williams, B. N. (2021). The relevance of inequality research in sociology for inequality reduction. Socius, 7, 1–30.
Dobbie, W., Goldin, J., & Yang, C. S. (2018). The effects of pre-trial detention on conviction, future crime, and employment: Evidence from randomly assigned judges. American Economic Review, 108(2), 201–240.
Dumont, D. M., Brockmann, B., Dickman, S., Alexander, N., & Rich, J. D. (2012). Public health and the epidemic of incarceration. Annual Review of Public Health, 33(1), 325–339.
Edwards, F., Lee, H., & Esposito, M. (2019). Risk of being killed by police use of force in the United States by age, race–ethnicity, and sex. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 116(34), 16793–16798.
Edwards, F., Wakefield, S., Healy, K., & Wildeman, C. (2021). Contact with child protective services is pervasive but unequally distributed by race and ethnicity in large US counties. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 118(30), e2106272118.
Enns, P. K., Yi, Y., Comfort, M., Goldman, A. W., Lee, H., Muller, C., Wakefield, S., Wang, E. A., & Wildeman, C. (2019). What percentage of Americans have ever had a family member incarcerated? Evidence from the Family History of Incarceration Survey (FamHIS). Socius, 5, 1–45.
Farrer, T. J., & Hedges, D. W. (2011). Prevalence of traumatic brain injury in incarcerated groups compared to the general population: A meta-analysis. Progress in Neuro-Psychopharmacology and Biological Psychiatry, 35(2), 390–394.
Finlay, K., & Mueller-Smith, M. (2021). Criminal Justice Administrative Records System (CJARS). https://cjars.isr.umich.edu/. Accessed 15 Nov 2022.
Finlay, K., Mueller-Smith, M., & Street, B. (2022). Measuring Intergenerational Exposure to the U.S. Justice System: Evidence from Longitudinal Links between Survey and Administrative Data. https://sites.lsa.umich.edu/mgms/wp-content/uploads/sites/283/2022/06/CJARS_KidExposure_20220609.pdf. Accessed 15 Nov 2022.
Foster, H., & Hagan, J. (2015). Punishment regimes and the multilevel effects of parental incarceration: Intergenerational, intersectional, and interinstitutional models of social inequality and systemic exclusion. Annual Review of Sociology, 41(1), 135–158.
Garland, D. (2001). The meaning of mass imprisonment. Punishment & Society, 3, 5–7.
Geller, A. (2021). Youth‒police contact: Burdens and inequities in an adverse childhood experience, 2014‒2017. American Journal of Public Health, 111(7), 1300–1308.
Geller, A., & Fagan, J. (2019). Police contact and the legal socialization of urban teens. RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences, 5(1), 26–49.
Gilmore, R. W. (2007). Golden Gulag: Prisons, Surplus, Crisis, and Opposition in Globalizing California. University of California Press.
Hagan, J., & Foster, H. (2012). Intergenerational educational effects of mass imprisonment in America. Sociology of Education, 85(3), 259–286.
Haney, C. (2018). Restricting the use of solitary confinement. Annual Review of Criminology, 1(1), 285–310.
Harcourt, B. E. (2015). Risk as a proxy for race: The dangers of risk assessment. Federal Sentencing Reporter, 27(4), 237–243.
Harding, D. J., Morenoff, J. D., Nguyen, A. P., & Bushway, S. D. (2018). Imprisonment and labor market outcomes: Evidence from a national experiment. American Journal of Sociology, 124(1), 49–110.
Haskins, A. R., & Jacobsen, W. C. (2017). Schools as surveilling institutions? Paternal incarceration, system avoidance, and parental involvement in schooling. American Sociological Review, 82(4), 657–684.
Hinton, E., & Cook, D. (2021). The mass criminalization of Black Americans: A historical overview. Annual Review of Criminology, 4(1), 261–286.
Kaba, F., Diamond, P., Haque, A., MacDonald, R., & Venters, H. (2014). Traumatic brain injury among newly admitted adolescents in the New York city jail system. The Journal of Adolescent Health: Official Publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine, 54(5), 615–617.
Kirk, D. S. (2016). Prisoner Reentry and the Reproduction of Legal Cynicism. Social Problems, 63(2), 222–243.
Kirk, D. S. (2019). Where the other 1 percent live: An examination of changes in the spatial concentration of the formerly incarcerated. RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences, 5(1), 255–274.
Kirk, D. S., & Papachristos, A. V. (2011). Cultural mechanisms and the persistence of neighborhood violence. American Journal of Sociology, 116(4), 1190–1233.
Kirk, D. S., & Wakefield, S. (2018). Collateral consequences of punishment: A critical review and path forward. Annual Review of Criminology, 1(1), 171–194.
Kohler-Hausmann, I. (2013). Misdemeanor justice: Control without conviction. American Journal of Sociology, 119(2), 351–393.
Kohler-Hausmann, I. (2019). Misdemeanorland. Princeton University Press.
Kurlychek, M. C., & Johnson, B. D. (2019). Cumulative disadvantage in the American criminal justice system. Annual Review of Criminology, 2(1), 291–319.
Lageson, S. E. (2020). Digital Punishment: Privacy, Stigma, and the Harms of Data-Driven Criminal Justice. Oxford University Press.
Lanuza, Y. R., Petersen, N., & Omori, M. (Forthcoming). Colorism in punishment among hispanics in the criminal justice system. Social Problems.
Lee, H., Esposito, M., Edwards, F., Chun, Y., & Grinstein-Weiss, M. (2020). The demographics of racial inequality in the United States. Brookings. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/up-front/2020/07/27/the-demographics-of-racial-inequality-in-the-united-states/. Accessed 15 Nov 2022.
Ludwig, J., & Mullainathan, S. (2021). Fragile algorithms and fallible decision-makers: Lessons from the justice system. The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 35(4), 71–96.
Lum, C., Koper, C. S., & Wu, X. (2022). Can we really defund the police? A nine-agency study of police response to calls for service. Police Quarterly, 25(3), 255–280.
Martin, K. D., Sykes, B. L., Shannon, S., Edwards, F., & Harris, A. (2018). Monetary sanctions: Legal financial obligations in US systems of justice. Annual Review of Criminology, 1(1), 471–495.
Maruna, S. (2001). Making Good: How Ex-Convicts Reform and Rebuild Their Lives. American Psychological Association.
Massoglia, M., & Pridemore, W. A. (2015). Incarceration and health. Annual Review of Sociology, 41(1), 291–310.
McKinley, J. (2020). The Bail Reform Backlash That Has Democrats at War. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/14/nyregion/new-york-bail-reform.html. Accessed 15 Nov 2022.
Mears, D. P. (2017). Out-of-Control Criminal Justice: The Systems Improvement Solution for More Safety, Justice, Accountability, and Efficiency. Cambridge University Press.
Mears, D. P., Cochran, J. C., & Lindsey, A. M. (2016a). Offending and racial and ethnic disparities in criminal justice: A conceptual framework for guiding theory and research and informing policy. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 32(1), 78–103.
Mears, D. P., Kuch, J. J., Lindsey, A. M., Siennick, S. E., Pesta, G. B., Greenwald, M. A., & Blomberg, T. G. (2016b). Juvenile court and contemporary diversion. Criminology & Public Policy, 15(3), 953–981.
Meyer, I. H., Flores, A. R., Stemple, L., Romero, A. P., Wilson, B. D. M., & Herman, J. L. (2017). Incarceration rates and traits of sexual minorities in the United States: National inmate survey, 2011–2012. American Journal of Public Health, 107(2), 267–273.
Miller, S. (2019). Ending prosecutor’s moral hazard in criminal sentencing current developments 2018–2019. Georgetown Journal of Legal Ethics, 32(4), 833–854.
Mueller-Smith, M., & Schnepel, K. T. (2021). Diversion in the criminal justice system. The Review of Economic Studies, 88(2), 883–936.
Muhammad, K. G. (2019). The Condemnation of Blackness: Race, Crime, and the Making of Modern Urban America, With a New Preface (2nd edition). Harvard University Press
Muller, C., Sampson, R. J., & Winter, A. S. (2018). Environmental inequality: The social causes and consequences of lead exposure. Annual Review of Sociology, 44(1), 263–282.
Murakawa, N., & Beckett, K. (2010). The penology of racial innocence: The erasure of racism in the study and practice of punishment. Law & Society Review, 44(3–4), 695–730.
Nalani, A., Yoshikawa, H., & Carter, P. L. (2021). Social science-based pathways to reduce social inequality in youth outcomes and opportunities at scale. Socius, 7, 1–17.
National Academies of Sciences. (2002). The Limits of Recidivism: Measuring Success After Prison. National Academies Press.
National Academies of Sciences. (2017). Proactive Policing: Effects on Crime and Communities.
National Research Council. (2014). The Growth of Incarceration in the United States: Exploring Causes and Consequences. National Academies Press.
Novick, R., & Pickett, J. T. (Forthcoming). Black Lives Matter, Protest Policing, and Voter Support for Police Reform in Portland, Oregon. Race and Justice.
Omi, M., & Winant, H. (2014). Racial Formation in the United States (3rd ed.). Routledge.
Petrich, D. M., Pratt, T. C., Jonson, C. L., & Cullen, F. T. (2021). Custodial sanctions and reoffending: A meta-analytic review. Crime and Justice, 50(1), 353–424.
Pettit, B. (2012). Invisible Men: Mass Incarceration and the Myth of Black Progress. Russell Sage Foundation.
Pettit, B., & Western, B. (2004). Mass imprisonment and the life course: Race and class inequality in U.S. incarceration. American Sociological Review, 69(2), 151–169.
Peyton, K., Sierra-Arévalo, M., & Rand, D. G. (2019). A field experiment on community policing and police legitimacy. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 116(40), 19894–19898.
Phelps, M. S. (2020). Mass probation from micro to macro: Tracing the expansion and consequences of community supervision. Annual Review of Criminology, 3(1), 261–279.
Reiss, A. J. J. (1981). Towards a revitalization of theory and research on victimization by crime. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 72, 704.
Reiter, K. (2016). 23/7: Pelican Bay Prison and the Rise of Long-Term Solitary Confinement. Yale University Press.
Remster, B., & Kramer, R. (2018). SHIFTING POWER: the impact of incarceration on political representation. Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race, 15(2), 417–439.
Rhodes, W., Gaes, G. G., Kling, R., & Cutler, C. (2018). Relationship between prison length of stay and recidivism: A study using regression discontinuity and instrumental variables with multiple break points. Criminology & Public Policy, 17(3), 731–769.
Ridgeway, C. L. (2014). Why status matters for inequality. American Sociological Review, 79(1), 1–16.
Shannon, S. K. S., Uggen, C., Schnittker, J., Thompson, M., Wakefield, S., & Massoglia, M. (2017). The growth, scope, and spatial distribution of people with felony records in the United States, 1948–2010. Demography, 54, 1795–1818.
Sierra-Arévalo, M. (2021). American policing and the danger imperative. Law & Society Review, 55(1), 70–103.
Soss, J., & Weaver, V. (2017). Police are our government: Politics, political science, and the policing of race-class subjugated communities. Annual Review of Political Science, 20(1), 565–591.
Steinberg, L. (2017). Adolescent brain science and juvenile justice policymaking. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 23(4), 410–420.
Stuart, F. (2016). Becoming “copwise”: Policing, culture, and the collateral consequences of street-level criminalization. Law & Society Review, 50(2), 279–313.
Tilly, C. (1999). Durable Inequality. University of California Press.
Tomaskovic-Devey, D., & Avent-Holt, D. (2019). Relational Inequalities: An Organizational Approach. Oxford University Press.
Turney, K. (2015). Liminal men: Incarceration and relationship dissolution. Social Problems, 62, 499–528.
Turney, K., & Wakefield, S. (2019). Criminal Justice Contact and Inequality. RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences, 5(1), 1–23.
Uggen, C., & Manza, J. (2002). Democratic contraction? Political consequences of felon disenfranchisement in the United States. American Sociological Review, 67(6), 777–803.
Wacquant, L. (2000). The new `peculiar institution’: On the prison as surrogate ghetto. Theoretical Criminology, 4(3), 377–389.
Wakefield, S., & Andersen, L. H. (2020). Pretrial detention and the costs of system overreach for employment and family life. Sociological Science, 7(14), 342–366.
Wakefield, S., & Uggen, C. (2010). Incarceration and stratification. Annual Review of Sociology, 36(1), 387–406.
Wakefield, S., & Wildeman, C. (2013). Children of the Prison Boom: Mass Incarceration and the Future of American Inequality. Oxford University Press.
Wakefield, S., & Wildeman, C. (2021). Structural racism, poverty, and sexism shape the history of and response to childhood maltreatment among incarcerated Individuals. American Journal of Public Health, 111(9), 1581–1583.
Weaver, V. M., Papachristos, A., & Zanger-Tishler, M. (2019). The great decoupling: The disconnection between criminal offending and experience of arrest across two cohorts. RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences, 5(1), 89–123.
Western, B. (2015). Lifetimes of violence in a sample of released prisoners. RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences, 1(2), 14–30.
Wildeman, C. (2009). Parental imprisonment, the prison boom, and the concentration of childhood disadvantage. Demography, 46, 265–280.
Wildeman, C. (2020). The intergenerational transmission of criminal justice contact. Annual Review of Criminology, 3(1), 217–244.
Wildeman, C., & Andersen, L. H. (2020). Solitary confinement placement and post-release mortality risk among formerly incarcerated individuals: A population-based study. Lancet Public Health, 5(2), 107–113.
Wildeman, C., & Wang, E. A. (2017). Mass incarceration, public health, and widening inequality in the USA. The Lancet, 389(10077), 1464–1474.
Wozniak, K. H. (2016). Public opinion and the politics of criminal justice policy making: Reasons for optimism, pessimism, and uncertainty. Criminology and Public Policy, 15(1), 179.
Yi, K. (2022). A Year After NJ Released Thousands Early From Prison, Only 9% Are Back in Custody. Gothamist: New York City Local News, Food, Arts & Events. https://gothamist.com/news/year-after-nj-released-thousands-early-prison-only-9-are-back-custody. Accessed 15 Nov 2022.
Zhang, M. (2022). Affirmative Algorithms: Relational Equality as Algorithmic Fairness. 2022 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency, 495–507.
Acknowledgements
The author greatly appreciates critical feedback on this essay provided by Daniel Mears, Robert Apel, and Christopher Wildeman.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
The author has no competing interests to declare that are relevant to the content of this article.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Wakefield, S. Criminal Justice Reform and Inequality. Am J Crim Just 47, 1186–1203 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12103-022-09717-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12103-022-09717-1