No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Giving and Taking Voice: Metapragmatic Dismissals of Parents in Child Welfare Court Cases
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 August 2023
Abstract
Applying tools of linguistic anthropology to ethnographic research conducted in a California child welfare court, this article analyzes how commentary by attorneys and judges about the language practices of parents and other communicative practices normalized the dismissal of the voices of marginalized lay actors throughout their cases. This commentary is an example of what linguistic anthropologists describe as “metapragmatic discourse,” or the use of language to foreground language itself and what language can accomplish in social exchanges. I introduce the concept of “metapragmatic dismissals” to describe how attorneys and judges in the child welfare context positioned parents’ language practices and overall personhood as suspect, often before parents even entered the courtroom. I identify practices of silencing, voicing figures of disbelief, and the use of metapragmatic labels of “lies” and “excuses” as common forms of metapragmatic dismissals that are supported by norms of court procedure, standards of evidence, and institutionalized discretion. This concept provides new insights into legal experiences in child welfare courts and, more generally, offers a valuable analytical framework for scholars who study the intersection of law, language, and power.
- Type
- Articles
- Information
- Copyright
- © The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the American Bar Foundation
Footnotes
She is a legal and linguistic anthropologist with a PhD in sociocultural anthropology from New York University. This article is based on research approved by the New York University Institutional Review Board and funded by the National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship Program grant number DGE1342536. Support from the American Bar Foundation Law and Inequality Fellowship and UC President’s Postdoctoral fellowship program provided valuable time to refine the research findings.
I am grateful to the parents, judges, and attorneys that agreed to participate in my study and allowed me to observe their time in court. I would also like to thank the doctoral fellows at the American Bar Foundation between 2019 and 2021 and the participants at the UC Irvine Center in Law, Society and Culture Socio-Legal Workshop, the UC San Diego Critical Anthropology Workshop, and the Law and Society Association Annual Meeting in July 2022 for their productive engagement with this scholarship. I received insightful feedback on this material from Sally Merry, Jonathan Rosa, Susan Coutin, Nancy Postero, Kaaryn Gustafson, Swethaa Ballakrishnen, Elizabeth Mertz, Charquia Wright, Mary Ellen Stitt, and Nancy Donald. Nancy Postero generously offered the phrase “socio-legal ecology” that I have used in this article in her discussant comments on this work at the UC San Diego Critical Anthropology workshop in April 2022. The reviewers provided important reflections that significantly aided the clarity and scope of this article. Many thanks to Breck Radulovic’s expert copyediting assistance. Any shortcomings of this article are mine alone.
References
REFERENCES
Agha, Asif. 1998. “Stereotypes and Registers of Honorific Language.” Language in Society, 27, no. 2: 151–193.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Agha, Asif. 2003. “The Social Life of Cultural Value.” Words and Beyond: Linguistic and Semiotic Studies of Sociocultural Order 23, no. 3–4: 231–73.Google Scholar
Agha, Asif. 2005. “Voice, Footing, Enregisterment.” Journal of Linguistic Anthropology 15, no. 1: 38–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Agyepong, Tera Eva. 2018. The Criminalization of Black Children: Race, Gender, and Delinquency in Chicago’s Juvenile Justice System, 1899-1945. Justice, Power, and Politics. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ahmad, Muneer I. 2002. “The Ethics of Narrative.” American University Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law 11, no. 1: 117–27.Google Scholar
Bakhtin, Mikhail M. 1981. Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays. Edited by Holquist, Michael. Translated by Emerson, Caryl and Holquist, Michael. Austin: University of Texas Press.Google Scholar
Baran, Dominika, and Holmquist, Quinn. 2018. “Immigrants Facing Linguistic Barriers in the U.S. Justice System.” In Language and Social Justice in Practice, edited by Avineri, Netta, Laura R Graham, Johnson, Eric J., Robin Conley Riner, and Rosa, Jonathan, 226–34. New York: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blumberg, Abraham S. 1967. “The Practice of Law as Confidence Game: Organizational Cooptation of a Profession.” Law & Society Review 1, no. 2: 15–39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bonilla-Silva, Eduardo. 2003. Racism without Racists Color-Blind Racism and the Persistence of Racial Inequality in the United States. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.Google Scholar
Bonilla-Silva, Eduardo, Lewis, Amanda, and David, Embrick. 2004. “‘I Did Not Get That Job Because of a Black Man…’: The Story Lines and Testimonies of Color-Blind Racism.” Sociological Forum 19, no. 4: 555–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brenneis, Donald. 1983. “Official Accounts: Performance and the Public Record.” The Windsor Yearbook of Access to Law 3:228–44.Google Scholar
Briggs, Laura. 2020. Taking Children: A History of American Terror. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Bucholtz, Mary. 2009. “Captured on Tape: Professional Hearing and Competing Entextualizations in the Criminal Justice System.” Text & Talk - An Interdisciplinary Journal of Language, Discourse & Communication Studies 29, no. 5: 503–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chandler, Alfred D. Jr. (1954) 1971. “The Origins of Progressive Leadership.” In Progressivism: The Critical Issues, edited by David, M Kennedy, chap. 7. Boston: Little Brown, and Company Inc.Google Scholar
Chávez-García, Miroslava. 2012. States of Delinquency: Race and Science in the Making of California’s Juvenile Justice System. Berkeley: University of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chu, Joon-Beom. 2020. “Losing Portia’s Voice: The Metapragmatic Evaluations of ‘Quiet’ and ‘Loud’ Female Law Students in US Mock Trial Competitions.” Journal of Linguistic Anthropology 30, no. 3: 353–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clair, Matthew. 2020. Privilege and Punishment: How Race and Class Matter in Criminal Court. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Clair, Matthew. 2021. “Being a Disadvantaged Criminal Defendant: Mistrust and Resistance in Attorney-Client Interactions.” Social Forces 100, no. 1: 194–217.Google Scholar
Conley, John M., and O’Barr, William M.. 1990. Rules Versus Relationships: The Ethnography of Legal Discourse. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Drake, Brett, and Pandey, Shanta. 1996. “Understanding the Relationship between Neighborhood Poverty and Specific Types of Child Maltreatment.” Child Abuse & Neglect 20, no. 11: 1003–18.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Edwards, Frank. 2019. “Family Surveillance: Police and the Reporting of Child Abuse and Neglect.” RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences 5, no. 1: 50–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Feliciano-Santos, Sherina. 2021. “Of Cops and ‘Karens’: Language and the Bureaucratic Arm of Policing.” Journal of Linguistic Anthropology 31, no. 2: 261–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fong, Kelley. 2020. “Getting Eyes in the Home: Child Protective Services Investigations and State Surveillance of Family Life.” American Sociological Review 85, no. 4: 610–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fong, Rowena, Dettlaff, Alan, James, Joyce, and Rodriguez, Carolyne. 2014. Addressing Racial Disproportionality and Disparities in Human Services: Multisystemic Approaches. New York: Columbia University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fox, Cybelle. 2012. Three Worlds of Relief: Race, Immigration, and the American Welfare State from the Progressive Era to the New Deal. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Glenn-Levin Rodriguez, Naomi. 2017. Fragile Families: Foster Care, Immigration, and Citizenship. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goodwin, Charles. 1994. “Professional Vision.” American Anthropologist 96, no. 3: 606–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gustafson, Kaaryn. 2014. “Degradation Ceremonies and the Criminalization of Low-Income Women.” University of California Irvine Law Review, 3, no. 2, article 7: 297–358.Google Scholar
He, Xin, and Ng, Kwai. 2013. “Pragmatic Discourse and Gender Inequality in China.” Law & Society Review 47, no. 2: 279–310.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hill, Jane. 1998. “Language, Race, and White Public Space.” American Anthropologist 100, no. 3: 680–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hill, Jane. 2008. The Everyday Language of White Racism. West Sussex, UK: Wiley-Blackwell.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hirsch, Susan F. 1998. Pronouncing & Persevering: Gender and the Discourses of Disputing in an African Islamic Court. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Inoue, Miyako. 2006. Vicarious Language: Gender and Linguistic Modernity in Japan. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
Irvine, Judith T. 1996. “Shadow Conversations: The Indeterminacy of Participant Roles.” In Natural Histories of Discourse, edited by Silverstein, Michael and Urban, Greg, 131–59. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Jones, Taylor, Rose Kalbfeld, Jessica, Hancock, Ryan, and Clark, Robin. 2019. “Testifying While Black: An Experimental Study of Court Reporter Accuracy in Transcription of African American English.” Language 95, no. 2: e216–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Keane, Webb. 2000. “Voice.” Journal of Linguistic Anthropology 9, no. 1–2: 271–73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Keane, Webb. 2011. “Indexing Voice: A Morality Tale.” Journal of Linguistic Anthropology 21, no. 2: 166–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kim, Hyunil, and Drake, Brett. 2018. “Child Maltreatment Risk as a Function of Poverty and Race/Ethnicity in the USA.” International Journal of Epidemiology 47, no. 3: 780–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lee, Tina. 2016. Catching a Case: Inequality and Fear in New York City’s Child Welfare System. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
Lens, Vicki. 2015. Poor Justice: How the Poor Fare in the Courts. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Lentin, Alana. 2018. “Beyond Denial: ‘Not Racism’ as Racist Violence.” Continuum 32, no. 4: 400–14.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lipsky, Michael. 2010. Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services, 30th anniversary expanded ed. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
López-Espino, Jessica. 2021. “Raciolinguistic Ideologies of ‘Spanish Speakers’ in a California Child Welfare Court.” In Metalinguistic Communities: Case Studies of Agency, Ideology, and Symbolic Uses of Language, edited by Netta Avineri and Jesse Harasta, 205–23. Palgrave Studies in Minority Languages and Communities. Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave MacMillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
López-Espino, Jessica. 2023. “Off-the-Record: Metapragmatic Distinctions and Linguistic Sympathy among Interpreters in a California Child Welfare Court.” American Anthropologist 125, no. 2: 225–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lucy, John A. 1993. “General Introduction.” In Reflexive Language Reported Speech and Metapragmatics, edited by John, A. Lucy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Matoesian, Gregory M. 1993. Reproducing Rape: Domination through Talk in the Courtroom. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Matoesian, Gregory M. 2001. Law and the Language of Identity: Discourse in the William Kennedy Smith Rape Trial. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Merry, Sally Engle. 1990. Getting Justice and Getting Even: Legal Consciousness among Working-Class Americans. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Mertz, Elizabeth. 1994. “Legal Language: Pragmatics, Poetics, and Social Power.” Annual Review of Anthropology 23:435–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mertz, Elizabeth. 2007. The Language of Law School Learning to “Think like a Lawyer.” Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nelson, Barbara J. 1984. Making an Issue of Child Abuse: Political Agenda Setting for Social Problems. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Nelson-Butler, Cheryl. 2013. “Blackness as Delinquency.” Washington University Law Review, 90, no. 5: 1335–1397.Google Scholar
Offit, Anna. 2022. “The Imagined Juror.” In The Imagined Juror. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Pardo, Rebecca. 2013. “Reality Television and the Metapragmatics of Racism.” Journal of Linguistic Anthropology 23, no. 1: 65–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Park, Joseph Sung-Yul, and Bucholtz, Mary. 2009. “Introduction. Public Transcripts: Entextualization and Linguistic Representation in Institutional Contexts” 29, no. 5: 485–502.Google Scholar
Pelton, Leroy H. 2015. “The Continuing Role of Material Factors in Child Maltreatment and Placement.” Child Abuse & Neglect 41, Supplement C: 30–39.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Powell, Amber Joy, Hlavka, Heather R., and Mulla, Sameena. 2017. “Intersectionality and Credibility in Child Sexual Assault Trials.” Gender & Society 31, no. 4: 457–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Raz, Mical. 2020. Abusive Policies: How the American Child Welfare System Lost Its Way. Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Razack, Sherene. 1998. Looking White People in the Eye: Gender, Race, and Culture in Courtrooms and Classrooms. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Razack, Sherene. 2000. “Gendered Racial Violence and Spatialized Justice: The Murder of Pamela George.” Canadian Journal of Law and Society 15, no. 2: 91–130.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reich, Jennifer A. 2005. Fixing Families: Parents, Power, and the Child Welfare System. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Reyes, Angela. 2011. “‘Racist!’: Metapragmatic Regimentation of Racist Discourse by Asian American Youth.” Discourse & Society 22, no. 4: 458–73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Richland, Justin B. 2007. “Pragmatic Paradoxes and Ironies of Indigeneity at the ‘Edge’ of Hopi Sovereignty.” American Ethnologist 34, no. 3: 540–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Richland, Justin B. 2008. Arguing with Tradition the Language of Law in Hopi Tribal Court. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rickford, John R., and King, Sharese. 2016. “Language and Linguistics on Trial: Hearing Rachel Jeantel (and Other Vernacular Speakers) in the Courtroom and Beyond.” Language 92, no. 4: 948–88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roberts, Dorothy. 2002. Shattered Bonds: The Color of Child Welfare. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Roberts, Dorothy. 2022. Torn Apart: How the Child Welfare System Destroys Black Families–-and How Abolition Can Build a Safer World. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Rock, Frances, Heffer, Chris, and Conley, John. 2013. “Textual Travel in Legal-Lay Communication.” In Textual Travel in Legal-Lay Communication, edited by Heffer, Chris, Rock, Frances, and John, M. Conley, 3–32. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rosa, Jonathan. 2016a. “Racializing Language, Regimenting Latinas/Os: Chronotope, Social Tense, and American Raciolinguistic Futures.” Language and Communication 46:106–17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rosa, Jonathan. 2016b. “Standardization, Racialization, Languagelessness: Raciolinguistic Ideologies across Communicative Contexts.” Journal of Linguistic Anthropology 26, no. 2: 162–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rosa, Jonathan. 2019. Looking like a Language, Sounding like a Race: Raciolinguistic Ideologies and the Learning of Latinidad. Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rosa, Jonathan, and Díaz, Vanessa. 2020. “Raciontologies: Rethinking Anthropological Accounts of Institutional Racism and Enactments of White Supremacy in the United States.” American Anthropologist 122, no. 1: 120–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sandefur, Rebecca. 2010. “The Impact of Counsel: An Analysis of Empirical Evidence.” Seattle Journal for Social Justice 9, no. 1: 51–95.Google Scholar
Sarat, Austin, and Felstiner, William L. F.. 1986. “Law and Strategy in the Divorce Lawyer’s Office.” Law & Society Review 20, no. 1: 93–134.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sedlak, Andrea J., McPherson, Karla, and Das, Barnali. 2010. Supplementary Analyses of Race Differences in Child Maltreatment Rates in the NIS-4. Office of Planning, Research & Evaluation, Administration for Children & Families. https://www.acf.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/opre/nis4_supp_analysis_race_diff_mar2010.pdf.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sedlak, Andrea J, Jane Mettenburg, Monica Basena, Ian Petta, Karla McPherson, Greene, Angela, and Li, Spencer. 2010. Fourth National Incidence Study of Child Abuse and Neglect (NIS-4). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Children and Families.Google Scholar
Silverstein, Michael. 1988. “De-Voice of Authority.” Paper presented at the American Anthropological Association Annual Meeting, Phoenix, AZ.Google Scholar
Silverstein, Michael. 1993. “Metapragmatic Discourse and Metapragmatic Function.” In Reflexive Language: Reported Speech and Metapragmatics, edited by John, A. Lucy, 33–58. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simmons, Michaela Christy. 2020. “Becoming Wards of the State: Race, Crime, and Childhood in the Struggle for Foster Care Integration, 1920s to 1960s.” American Sociological Review 85, no. 2: 199–222.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Urban, G. 2006. “Metasemiosis and Metapragmatics.” In Encyclopedia of Language & Linguistics, edited by Brown, Keith, 88–91. Amsterdam: Elsevier.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. 2018. The AFCARS Report 25. Preliminary FY 2017 Estimates as of August 10, 2018. Administration for Children and Families, Children’s Bureau. https://www.acf.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/cb/afcarsreport25.pdf.Google Scholar
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Children and Families, Administration on Children, Youth and Families, Administration of Children and Families, Administration on Children, Youth and Families, and Children’s Bureau. 2021. Child Maltreatment 2019. https://www.acf.hhs.gov/cb/research-data-technology/statistics-research/child-maltreatment.Google Scholar
Cleve, Van, and Gonzalez, Nicole. 2022. “Due Process & the Theater of Racial Degradation: The Evolving Notion of Pretrial Punishment in the Criminal Courts.” Daedalus 151, no. 1: 135–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wortham, Stanton, and Reyes, Angela. 2015. Discourse Analysis beyond the Speech Event. 1st edition. London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
STATUTES CITED
California Welfare & Institutions Code § 300 (1976).Google Scholar
California Welfare & Institutions Code § 355 (2015).Google Scholar
California Welfare & Institutions Code § 388 (2012).Google Scholar