No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Designing Competition Clauses in Preferential Trade Agreements
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 13 October 2023
Abstract
Competition policy is one important aspect of trade liberalization. However, when examining preferential trade agreements (PTAs), a major type of policy tools to liberalize trade, competition provisions are revealed not to be uniformly distributed across these treaties. What explains the variation in the design of competition clauses in PTAs? Borrowing insights from the rational design of international institutions and combining them with those from treaty ratification and policy diffusion literatures, I identify five major causal mechanisms through which competition provisions are incorporated into PTAs. In evaluating them, I employ a range of operationalization techniques to capture the proposed mechanisms. A treaty-level analysis of 319 PTAs over the period 1960–2015 lends strong and robust support to most of the hypothesized relationships. By integrating theoretical frameworks across international political economy literatures with that from law and economics scholarship, this study demonstrates the utility of political science thinking to the real-world international law-making.
Keywords
- Type
- Original Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of The World Trade Organization
References
Abbott, K.W. and Snidal, D. (2000) ‘Hard and Soft Law in International Governance’, International Organization 54(3), 421–456.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Allee, T. and Peinhardt, C. (2010) ‘Delegating Differences: Bilateral Investment Treaties and Bargaining over Dispute Resolution Provisions’, International Studies Quarterly 54, 1–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Allee, T. and Peinhardt, C. (2014) ‘Evaluating Three Explanations for the Design of Bilateral Investment Treaties’, World Politics 66(01), 47–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Allee, T. and Elsig, M. (2016) ‘Why Do Some International Institutions Contain Strong Dispute Settlement Provisions? New Evidence from Preferential Trade Agreements’, The Review of International Organizations 11(1), 89–120.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Allee, T. and Elsig, M. (2019) ‘Are the Contents of International Treaties Copied and Pasted? Evidence from Preferential Trade Agreements’, International Studies Quarterly 63(3), 603–613.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Allee, T., Elsig, M., and Lugg, A. (2017) ‘The Ties between the World Trade Organization and Preferential Trade Agreements: A Textual Analysis’, Journal of International Economic Law 20(2), 333–363.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Anderson, R.D., Kovacic, W.E., Müller, A.C., and Sporysheva, N. (2018) ‘Competition Policy, Trade and the Global Economy: Existing WTO Elements, Commitments in Regional Trade Agreements, Current Challenges and Issues for Reflection’, WTO Staff Working Papers ERSD-2018-12. World Trade Organization (WTO), Economic Research and Statistics Division.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baccini, L. and Koenig-Archibugi, M. (2014) ‘Why Do States Commit to International Labour Standards? The importance of ‘Rivalry’ and ‘Friendship’’, World Politics 66(3), 446–490.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baccini, L. and Dür, A. (2015) ‘Investment Discrimination and the Proliferation of Preferential Trade Agreements’, Journal of Conflict Resolution 59(4), 617–644.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baccini, L., Dür, A., and Elsig, M. (2013) ‘Depth, Flexibility and International Cooperation: The Politics of Trade Agreement Design’, in ISA Annual Conference. San Francisco, CA.Google Scholar
Baccini, L., Dür, A., and Elsig, M. (2015) ‘The Politics of Trade Agreement Design: Revisiting the Depth–Flexibility Nexus’, International Studies Quarterly 59(4), 765–775.Google Scholar
Barbieri, K. and Omar Keshk, O.M.G. (2016) ‘Correlates of War Project Trade Data Set Codebook, Version 4.0’.Google Scholar
Bartók, C. and Miroudot, S. (2008) ‘The Interactions amongst Trade, Investment, and Competition Policies’, Trade Policy Papers No. 60. Paris: OECD Publishing, http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/241467172568.Google Scholar
Berliner, D., Greenleaf, A., Lake, M., and Noveck, J. (2015) ‘Building Capacity, Building Rights? State Capacity and Labor Rights in Developing Countries’, World Development 72, 127–139.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bhattacharjea, A. (2006) ‘The Case for a Multilateral Agreement on Competition Policy: A Developing Country Perspective’, Journal of International Economic Law 9(2), 293–323.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blackhurst, R. (1991) ‘Trade Policy is Competition Policy’, in Competition and Economic Development, Paris: OECD, 2532–2558.Google Scholar
Bond, E.W. (2013) ‘Trade Policy and Competition Policy: Conflict vs. Mutual Support’, in Neumann, M., and Weigand, J. (eds.), The International Handbook of Competition. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.Google Scholar
Bradford, A. and Büthe, T. (2015) ‘Competition Policy and Free Trade: Antitrust Provisions in PTAs’, in Dür, A. and Elsig, M. (eds.), Trade Cooperation: The Purpose, Design and Effects of Preferential Trade Agreements. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 246–274.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bradford, A. and Chilton, A.S. (2018) ‘Competition Law around the World from 1889 to 2010: The Competition Law Index’, Journal of Competition Law & Economics 14(3), 393–432.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bradford, A. and Chilton, A.S. (2019) ‘Trade Openness and Antitrust Law’, The Journal of Law and Economics 62(1), 29–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bradford, A. and Chilton, A. (2021) ‘Regulating Antitrust through Trade Agreements’, Antitrust Law Journal 84(1), 103–125.Google Scholar
Brandi, C., Schwab, J., Berger, A., and Morin, J.-F. (2020) ‘Do Environmental Provisions in Trade Agreements Make Exports from Developing Countries Greener?’, World Development 129, 104899.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brusick, P., Alvarez, A.M., and Cernat, L. (2005) Competition Provisions in Regional Trade Agreements: How to Assure Development Gains. New York and Geneva: UN Publications.Google Scholar
Büthe, T. (2007) ‘The Politics of Competition and Institutional Change in the European Union: The First Fifty Years’, in Meunier, S. and McNamara, K. (eds.), Making History: European Integeration and Institutional Change at Fifty (State of the European Union, vol.8). Oxford: Oxford University Press, 175–193.Google Scholar
Büthe, T. (2019) ‘Competition Law and Policy as an IPE Issue’, in Shaw, T.M., Mahrenbach, L.C., Modi, R., and Yi-chong, X. (eds.), The Palgrave Handbook of Contemporary International Political Economy, 447–463.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Büthe, T. and Milner, H.V. (2008) ‘The Politics of Foreign Direct Investment into Developing Countries: Increasing FDI through International Trade Agreements?’, American Journal of Political Science 52(4), 741–762.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Büthe, T. and Milner, H.V. (2014) ‘Foreign Direct Investment and Institutional Diversity in Trade Agreements: Credibility, Commitment, and Economic Flows in the Developing World, 1971–2007’, World Politics 66(01), 88–122.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Büthe, T. and Cho, M. (2017) ‘Power and Institutionalized International Regulatory Cooperation: A Multi-Method Analysis of Antitrust Agreements’, European Foreign Affairs Review 22, 115–136.Google Scholar
Cernat, L. (2005) ‘Eager to Ink, But Ready to Act? RTA Proliferation and International Cooperation on Competition Policy’, in Brusick, P., Alvarez, A.M., and Cernat, L. (eds.), Competition Provisions in Regional Trade Agreements: How to Assure Development Gains. New York and Geneva: United Nations, 1–36.Google Scholar
Checkel, J. (2005) ‘International Institutions and Socialization in Europe: Introduction and Framework’, International Organization 59(Fall), 801–826.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cheng, T.K. (2020) Competition Law in Developing Countries. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, Incorporated.Google Scholar
Cheong, D. and Kim, S.Y. (2022) ‘Confirming the Status Quo: The Political Economy of EU–ACP Economic Partnership Agreements’, Journal of European Public Policy 29(3), 448–467.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cole, W.M. (2015) ‘Mind the Gap: State Capacity and the Implementation of Human Rights Treaties’, International Organization 69, 405–441.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Copelovitch, M.S. and Putnam, T.L. (2014) ‘Design in Context: Existing International Agreements and New Cooperation’, International Organization 68(02), 471–493.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Crescenzi, M.J.C., Kthman, J.D., Keinberg, K.B., and Wood, R.M. (2012) ‘Reliability, Reputation, and Alliance Formation’, International Studies Quarterly 56(2), 259–274.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dai, X. (2005) ‘Why Comply? The Domestic Constituency Mechanism’, International Organization 59(2), 363–398.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dawar, K. and Holmes, P. (2011) ‘Competition Policy’, in Chauffour, J.-P. and Maur, J.-C. (eds.), Preferential Trade Agreement Policies for Development: a Handbook. Washington, DC: World Bank, 347–366.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dawar, K. and Holmes, P. (2012) ‘Trade and Competition Policy’, in Heydon, K. and Woolcock, S. (eds.), The Ashgate Research Companion to International Trade Policy. Oxfordshire, UK: Routledge, 251–270.Google Scholar
Downs, G.W., Rocke, D.M., and Barsoom, P.N. (1996) ‘Is the Good News about Compliance Good News about Cooperation?’, International Organization 50(3), 379–406.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dür, A., Baccini, L., and Elsig, M. (2014) ‘The Design of International Trade Agreements: Introducing a New Database’, Review of International Organizations 9(3), 353–375.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Elkins, Z., Guzman, A.T., and Simmons, B.A. (2006) ‘Competing for Capital: The Diffusion of Bilateral Investment Treaties, 1960–2000’, International Organization 60(04), 811–846.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fearon, J.D. (1997) ‘Signaling Foreign Policy Interests: Tying Hands versus Sinking Costs’, The Journal of Conflict Resolution 41(1), 68–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Finnemore, M. (1996) National Interests in International Society. Ithca and London: Cornell University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Freeman, N.W. (2013) ‘Domestic Institutions, Capacity Limitations, and Compliance Costs: Host Country Determinants of Investment Treaty Arbitrations, 1987–2007’, International Interactions 39(1), 54–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gerber, D.J. (2007) ‘Competition Law and the WTO: Rethinking the Relationship’, Journal of International Economic Law 10(3), 269–286.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goodliffe, J. and Hawkins, D.G. (2006) ‘Explaining Commitment: States and the Convention against Torture’, Journal of Politics 68(2), 358–371.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Guzman, A.T. (1998) ‘Is International Antitrust Possible?’, New York University Law Review 73(5), 1501–1548.Google Scholar
Guzman, A. (2004) ‘The Case for International Antitrust’, Berkeley Journal of International Law 22(3), 355–374.Google Scholar
Hafner-Burton, E.M., Victor, D.G., and Lupu, Y. (2017) ‘Political Science Research on International Law: The State of the Field’, American Journal of International Law 106(1), 47–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hanrieder, T. (2014) ‘The Path-Dependent Design of International Organizations: Federalism in the World Health Organization’, European Journal of International Relations 21(1), 215–239.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hanson, J.K. and Sigman, R. (2021) ‘Leviathan's Latent Dimensions: Measuring State Capacity for Comparative Political Research’, The Journal of Politics 83(4), 1495–1510.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Helpman, E. and Krugman, P.R. (1989) Trade Policy and Market Structure. Cambridge. MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Hoekman, B. and Mavroidis, P.C.. (2002) ‘Economic Development, Competition Policy and the WTO’, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 2917.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Holmes, P., Sydorak, A., Papadopoulos, A., and Kayali, B.Ö. (2005) ‘Trade and Competition in RTAs: A Missed Opportunity?’, in Brusick, P., Alvarez, A.M., and Cernat, L. (eds.), Competition Provisions in Regional Trade Agreements: How to Assure Development Gains. New York and Geneva: United Nations, 65–122.Google Scholar
Horn, H. and Levinsohn, J. (2001) ‘Merger Policies and Trade Liberalisation’, The Economic Journal 111(470), 244–276.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hufbauer, G. and Kim, J. (2009) ‘International Competition Policy and the WTO’, The Antitrust Bulletin 54(2), 327–335.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ikejiaku, B. and Dayao, C. (2021) ‘Competition Law as an Instrument of Protectionist Policy: Comparative Analysis of the EU and the US’, Utrecht Journal of International and European Law 36(1), 75–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jackson, J.H. (2006) Sovereignty, the WTO, and Changing Fundamentals of International Law. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jenny, F. (2020) ‘An Essay: Can Competition Law and Policy Be Made Relevant for Inclusive Growth of Developing Countries?’, The Antitrust Bulletin 65(1), 164–172.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jo, H. and Namgung, H. (2012) ‘Dispute Settlement Mechanisms in Preferential Trade Agreements: Democracy, Boilerplates, and the Multilateral Trade Regime’, The Journal of Conflict Resolution 56(6), 1041–1068.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kahler, M. (2003) ‘Conclusion: The Causes and Consequences of Legalization’, International Organization 54(3), 661–683.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kelley, J. (2004) ‘International Actors on the Domestic Scene: Membership Conditionality and Socialization by International Institutions’, International Organization 58(Summer), 425–457.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Keohane, R.O. (1986) ‘Reciprocity in International Relations’, International Organizations 40(1), 1–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Koremenos, B. (2005) ‘Contracting around International Uncertainty’, American Political Science Review 99(04), 549–565.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Koremenos, B., Lipson, C., and Snidal, D. (2001) ‘The Rational Design of International Institutions’, International Organization 55(04), 761–799.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Laprévote, F.-C. (2019) ‘Competition Policy within the Context of Free Trade Agreements’, in the 18th Global Forum on Competition.Google Scholar
Lechner, L. (2016) ‘The Domestic Battle over the Design of Non-Trade Issues in Preferential Trade Agreements’, Review of International Political Economy 23(5), 840–871.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leeds, B.A., Mattes, M., and Vogel, J.S. (2009) ‘Interests, Institutions, and the Reliability of International Commitments’, American Journal of Political Science 53(2), 461–476.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mansfield, E.D., Milner, H.V., and Peter Rosendorff, B. (2002) ‘Why Democracies Cooperate More: Electoral Control and International Trade Agreements’, International Organization 56(3), 477–513.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marshall, M.G. and Jaggers, K. (2012) Polity IV Project: Political Regime Characteristics and Transitions, 1800–2012: Dataset Users’ Manual. Maryland: University of Maryland.Google Scholar
Mathis, J. (2005) ‘North–South Cooperation Instruments: The Effectiveness and Impediments for Bilateral Approaches to Cross-Border AntiTrust Enforcement’, in Paper for CEPR project.Google Scholar
Melitz, M.J. and Ottaviano, G.I.P. (2008) ‘Market Size, Trade, and Productivity’, The Review of Economic Studies 75(1), 295–316.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morin, J.-F., Pauwelyn, J., and Hollway, J. (2017) ‘The Trade Regime as a Complex Adaptive System: Innovation and Diffusion of Environmental Norms in Trade Agreements’, Journal of International Economic Law 20(2), 365–390.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morrow, J. (1999) ‘The Strategic Setting of Choices: Signaling, Commitmment, and Negotiation in International Politics’, in Lake, D.A. and Powell, R. (eds.), Strategic Choice and International Relations. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 77–144.Google Scholar
Noonan, C. and Plekhanova, V. (2020) ‘Taxation of Digital Services under Trade Agreements’, Journal of International Economic Law 23(4), 1015–1039.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
OECD (2005) Competition Provisions in Regional Trade Agreements: Part I. Secretariat Paper. Paris: Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development.Google Scholar
Papadopoulos, A.S. (2010) The International Dimension of EU Competition Law and Policy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pierson, P. (2000) ‘Path Dependence, Increasing Returns, and Political Science’, American Political Science Review 94(2), 251–267.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Raess, D., Dür, A., and Sari, D. (2018) ‘Protecting Labor Rights in Preferential Trade Agreements: The Role of Trade Unions, Left Governments, and Skilled Labor’, The Review of International Organizations 13(2), 143–162.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Richardson, M. (1999) ‘Trade and Competition Policies: Concordia discors?’, Oxford Economic Papers 51(4), 649–664.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rosendorff, B.P. and Milner, H.V. (2001) ‘The Optimal Design of International Trade Institutions: Uncertainty and Escape’, International Organization 55(04), 829–857.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schultz, K.A. (1998) ‘Domestic Opposition and Signaling in International Crises’, The American Political Science Review 92(4), 829–844.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simmons, B.A. (2003) ‘The Legalization of International Monetary Affairs’, International Organization 54(3), 573–602.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simmons, B.A. (2014) ‘Bargaining over BITs, Arbitrating Awards: The Regime for Protection and Promotion of International Investment’, World Politics 66(1), 12–46.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sokol, D.D. (2008) ‘Order without (Enforceable) Law: Why Countries Enter into Non-Enforceable Competition Policy Chapters in Free Trade Agreements’, Chicago-Kent Law Review 83(1), 231–292.Google Scholar
Teh, R. (2009) ‘Competition Provisions in Regional Trade Agreements’, in Estevadeordal, A., Suominen, K., and Teh, R. (eds.), Regional Rules in the Global Trading System. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 418–491.Google Scholar
Thompson, A. (2010) ‘Rational Design in Motion: Uncertainty and Flexibility in the Global Climate Regime’, European Journal of International Relations 16(2), 269–296.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thompson, A., Broude, T., and Haftel, Y.Z. (2019) ‘Once Bitten, Twice Shy? Investment Disputes, State Sovereignty, and Change in Treaty Design’, International Organization 73(4), 859–880.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tomz, M. (2007) Reputation and International Cooperation: Sovereign Debt across Three Centuries. Princeton. NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Voigt, S. (2009) ‘The Effects of Competition Policy on Development – Cross-Country Evidence Using Four New Indicators’, The Journal of Development Studies 45(8), 1225–1248.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
von Stein, J. (2015) ‘Making Promises, Keeping Promises: Democracy, Ratification and Compliance in International Human Rights Law’, British Journal of Political Science 46(3), 655–679.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vreeland, J. (2008) ‘Political Institutions and Human Rights: Why Dictatorships Enter into the United Nations Convention aginst Torture’, International Organization 62(1), 65–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wang, Z. (2016) ‘Treaty Commitment as a Signaling Device: Explaining the Ratification of the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights’, Human Rights Review 17, 193–220.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wang, Z. (2020) ‘Thinking Outside the Box: Globalization, Labor Rights, and the Making of Preferential Trade Agreements’, International Studies Quarterly 64(2), 343–355.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wesley, M. (2008) ‘The Strategic Effects of Preferential Trade Agreements’, Australian Journal of International Affairs 62(2), 214–228.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
World Trade Organization (1997) ‘Special Study on Trade and Competition Policy’, WTO Annual Report.Google Scholar
World Trade Organization, Doha Work Program (2004) ‘Decision Adopted by the General Council on 1 August 2004, WT/L/579 (Aug. 2, 2004)’.Google Scholar
Wang supplementary material
File
579.6 KB