Abstract
Recently, Uriah Kriegel and Mark Timmons have suggested a “phenomenology of Kantian Respect for Persons”. They offer a reconstruction of Kant’s own account of the phenomenology of respect for persons as well as a refinement of their own. I shall argue that at least with regard to their reconstruction of Kant’s account, they do not succeed. There are a number of shortcomings, the most grievous of which is that Kant does offer a detailed phenomenology of respect in his second Critique which Kriegel and Timmons, however, pay no attention to.
Literature
Berger, Larissa: Kants Philosophie des Schönen: Eine kommentarische Interpretation zu den §§ 1–22 der Kritik der Urteilskraft. Baden-Baden 2022.10.5771/9783495825440-1Search in Google Scholar
Darwall, Stephen: “Two Kinds of Respect.” In: Ethics 88, 1977, 36–49.10.1086/292054Search in Google Scholar
Fahmy, Melissa S.: “Active Sympathetic Participation: Reconsidering Kant’s Duty of Sympathy.” In: Kantian Review 14 (1), 2009, 31–52.10.1017/S1369415400001333Search in Google Scholar
Kriegel, Uriah & Timmons, Mark: “The Phenomenology of Kantian Respect for Persons.” In: Respect. Philosophical Essays. Ed. by R. Dean and O. Sensen. Oxford 2021, 77–98.10.1093/oso/9780198824930.003.0004Search in Google Scholar
Schmidt, Elke E.: Liebe und Bedeutsamkeit. Ein philosophischer Versuch. Paderborn 2022.10.30965/9783969752494_005Search in Google Scholar
Schönecker, Dieter: “Kant on Menschenliebe as a Moral Predisposition of the Mind”. In: Kant on Sex, Love, and Friendship. Ed. by Pärttyli Rinne and Martin Brecher. Berlin/Boston 2023, 107–126.10.1515/9783111291130-007Search in Google Scholar
Schönecker, Dieter: “Das gefühlte Faktum der Vernunft. Skizze einer Interpretation und Verteidigung”. In: Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie 61 (1), 2013 [a], 91–107.10.1524/dzph.2013.0006Search in Google Scholar
Schönecker, Dieter: “Kant’s Moral Intuitionism. The Fact of Reason and Moral Predispositions.” In: Kant Studies Online, Feb. 2013[b], 1–38.Search in Google Scholar
Schönecker, Dieter: “Achtung”. In: Kleines Kant-Lexikon. Hrsg. von L. Berger und E. E. Schmidt. Paderborn 2018, 104–105.Search in Google Scholar
© 2024 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
