Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-dfsvx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-27T23:35:04.740Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Future of Periodization. Dissecting the Legacy of Culture History

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 March 2024

Gavin Lucas Open the ORCID record for Gavin Lucas [Opens in a new window]  and
Orri Vésteinsson Open the ORCID record for Orri Vésteinsson [Opens in a new window]
Gavin Lucas
Affiliation:
Department of Archaeology University of Iceland Sæmundargötu 2 102 Reykjavík Iceland Email: gavin@hi.is
Orri Vésteinsson
Affiliation:
Department of Archaeology University of Iceland Sæmundargötu 2 102 Reykjavík Iceland Email: orri@hi.is
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper discusses the future role of periodization in the wake of recent critiques of culture-historical chronologies concurrent with the rise of high-definition radiocarbon dating. It is argued that periodization has two distinct facets, a narrative function and a dating function, which should be separated. Archaeology may eventually be able to abandon the latter, but not the former. However, the two aspects are closely intertwined and the goal of this paper is to disentangle them and, through a case study of archaeological periodization in Iceland, demonstrate the need to re-engage with culture-historical taxonomies by reverse engineering their construction. Only in this way will the utility or poverty of such culture-historical periods be exposed to proper scrutiny and the ground cleared for building new, narrative periodizations.

Type
Research Article
Information
Cambridge Archaeological Journal , First View , pp. 1 - 16
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Árnason, Á.D., 2018. Milli steins og sleggju. Eru allar steinsleggjur fiskasleggjur? [Between a Rock and a Hard Place. Are All Stone Hammers Fish Tenderizers?]. BA thesis, University of Iceland.Google Scholar
Barraclough, G., 1955. History in a Changing World. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Batey, C., 2011. Hofstaðir: does the artefact assemblage reflect its special status?, in Viking Settlements and Viking Society. Papers from the Proceedings of the Sixteenth Viking Congress, ed. Sigmundsson, S.. Reykjavik: University of Iceland Press, 18–30.Google Scholar
Bayliss, A., 2009. Rolling out revolution: using radiocarbon dating in archaeology. Radiocarbon 51(1), 123–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bayliss, A. & Whittle, A., 2019. What kind of history is prehistory?, in Time and History in Prehistory, eds Souvatzi, S., Baysal, A. & Baysal, E.. London: Routledge, 123–46.Google Scholar
Beck, S.G., 2020. Quernstones and Craftsmanship. Diffusion of Innovation in Pre-Industrial Iceland. PhD thesis, University of Iceland.Google Scholar
Bigelow, G.F., 1985. Sandwick Unst and the Late Norse Shetlandic economy, in Shetland Archaeology: New work in Shetland in the 1970s, ed. Smith, B.. Lerwick: Shetland Times Press, 95–127.Google Scholar
Bolender, D.J., Steinberg, J.M. & Damiata, B.N., 2011. Farmstead reorganization at the end of the Viking Age. Results of the Skagafjörður archaeological settlement survey. Archaeologia Islandica 9, 77–101.Google Scholar
Childe, V.G., 1951. Social Evolution. London: Watts & Co.Google Scholar
Courtney, P., 1997. The tyranny of constructs: some thoughts on periodisation and culture change, in Age of Transition: The archaeology of English culture, 1400–1600, eds Gaimster, D. & Stamper, P.. Oxford: Oxbow, 9–24.Google Scholar
Crellin, R., 2017. Changing assemblages: vibrant matter in burial assemblages. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 27(1), 111–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Crellin, R., 2020. Change and Archaeology. London: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Einarsson, Á., 2019. Tíminn sefur. Fornaldargarðarnir miklu á Íslandi [Time sleeps. Extensive ancient boundaries in Iceland]. Reykjavik: Mál og menning.Google Scholar
Einarsson, Á., Hansson, O. & Vésteinsson, O., 2002. An extensive system of Medieval earthworks in northeast Iceland. Archaeologia Islandica 2, 61–73.Google Scholar
Einarsson, B.F., 1994. Íslenskar fornleifar: Fórnarlömb sagnahyggjunnar? [Icelandic archaeology: a victim of saga-bias?]. Skírnir 168, 377–402.Google Scholar
Einarsson, B.F., 2020. Bærinn sem hvarf í ösku og eldi 1362. Hamfarir, eldgos og mannlíf [The farm that disappeared in ash and fire in 1362. Disasters, volcanic eruptions and daily life]. Reykjavik: Skrudda.Google Scholar
Eldjárn, K. 1956. Kuml og haugfé úr heiðnum sið á Íslandi [Viking burial practices in Iceland]. Akureyri: Norðri.Google Scholar
Fagerland, T.E. & Paasche, K. (eds), 2011. 1537—Kontinuitet eller brudd? [1537 – Continuity or rupture?]. Trondheim: Tapir Academic Press.Google Scholar
Forster, A., 2004. Shetland and the Trade of Steatite Goods in the North Atlantic Region during the Viking and Early Medieval Period. PhD thesis, University of Bradford.Google Scholar
Friðriksson, A., 1994. Sannfræði íslenskra fornleifa [Historicity and Icelandic archaeology]. Skírnir 168, 346–76.Google Scholar
Gardiner, M. & Mehler, N., 2013. Introduction: German trade in the North Atlantic, in German Trade in the North Atlantic c. 1400–1700. Interdisciplinary perspectives, eds Mehler, N., Gardiner, M. & Elvestad, E.. (AmS Skrifter 27.) Stavanger: Arkeologisk Museum Stavanger, 9–24.Google Scholar
Gerhard, E., 1956. Periodization in European history. American Historical Review 61(4), 900–913.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gestsson, G., 1959. Gröf í Öræfum [Gröf in the district of Öræfi]. Árbók hins íslenzka fornleifafélags 1959, 5–87.Google Scholar
Gísladóttir, G.A. & Snæsdóttir, M., 2011. Steinar fyrir brauð. Norsk eldhústíska á Íslandi [Stones for bread. Nordic culinary customs in Iceland], in Upp á yfirborðið. Nýjar rannsóknir í íslenskri fornleifafræði [Up on the surface. New research in Icelandic archaeology], eds Vésteinsson, O., Lucas, G., Þórsdóttir, K. & Gylfadóttir, R.G.. Reykjavik: Fornleifastofnun Íslands, 51–68.Google Scholar
Gísladóttir, G.A. & Snæsdóttir, M., 2019. Jarðfundnir kambar á Íslandi frá landnámi til 1800 [Excavated combs found in Iceland from the settlement to 1800]. Árbók hins íslenzka fornleifafélags 108, 7–54.Google Scholar
Graeber, D. & Wengrow, D., 2021. The Dawn of Everything. A new history of humanity. New York (NY): Picador.Google Scholar
Green, W., 1992. Periodization in European and world history. Journal of World History 3(1), 13–53.Google Scholar
Griffiths, D., 2023. Chapter 1: Landnám and landscape in Viking Orkney, in The Viking Age in Scotland, eds Horne, T., Pierce, E. & Barrowman, R.. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 13–28.Google Scholar
Griffiths, S., 2017. We're all culture historians now: radiocarbon dating revolutions and archaeological theory. Radiocarbon 59, 1347–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Griffiths, S., Carlin, N., Edwards, B., Overton, N., Johnston, P. & Thomas, J., 2023. Events, narrative and data: why new chronologies or ethically Bayesian approaches should change how we write archaeology. Journal of Social Archaeology 23(2), 173–92.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Guðjónsson, E.E., 1985. Um prjón á Íslandi [On knitting in Iceland]. Hugur og hönd 1985, 8–12.Google Scholar
Guðmundsdóttir, J.Þ., 2012. ‘Ætli menn þyrftu ekki að byrja á að bæta smekk sinn?’ Viðreisn garðræktar á síðari hluta 18. Aldar [’Shouldn't People Start by Improving Their Taste?’ The Regeneration of Horticulture in the Latter Part of the 18th Century]. MA thesis, University of Iceland.Google Scholar
Guðmundsdóttir, J.V., 2023. Vefst staðurinn fyrir okkur? Rannsókn á staðsetningu vefstaðarins á Íslandi á víkingaöld og miðöldum út frá kljásteinafundum [A Place For Us. Research on the Location of Looms in Iceland in the Viking and Medieval Period based on Loom Weights]. MA thesis, University of Iceland.Google Scholar
Hansen, S.C.J., 2011. The Icelandic whetstone material – an overview of recent research. Archaeologia Islandica 9, 65–76.Google Scholar
Hayeur Smith, M., 2012. ‘Some in rags and some in jags and some in silken gowns’: textiles from Iceland's Early Modern Period. International Journal of Historical Archaeology 16(3), 509–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hayeur Smith, M., 2015. Weaving wealth: cloth and trade in Viking Age and Medieval Iceland, in Textiles and the Medieval Economy: Production, trade, and consumption of textiles, 8th–16th centuries, eds Ling Huang, A. & Jahnke, C.. Oxford: Oxbow, 23–40.Google Scholar
Hreiðarsdóttir, E.Ó., 2007. Medieval and Early Modern beads from Iceland. Archaeologia Islandica 6, 9–31.Google Scholar
Hreiðarsdóttir, E.Ó., 2010. Icelandic Viking Age beads. Their origin and characteristics. Ornament 33(5), 64–7.Google Scholar
Ingólfsson, S., 2023. Af nýjum sjónarhóli: Breytingar á húsagerð á Norðurlöndum á mörkum víkingaaldar og miðalda [From a New Perspective: Changes in House Construction in the Nordic Countries During the Transition between the Viking and Middle Ages]. MA thesis, University of Iceland.Google Scholar
Jonsson, K., 2009. Eastern contacts based on the coin finds. Situne Dei 2009, 57–67.Google Scholar
Kålund, P.E.K., 1882. Islands fortidslævninger [Icelandic antiquities]. Aarbøger for nordisk oldkyndighed og historie 1882, 57–124.Google Scholar
Kristjánsdóttir, S., 2023. Monastic Iceland. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Le Goff, J., 2015. Must We Divide History into Periods? New York (NY): Columbia University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leifsson, R., 2018. Ritual Animal Killing and Burial Custom in Viking Age Iceland. PhD thesis, University of Iceland.Google Scholar
Líndal, S. (ed,), 1974–2016. Saga Íslands (11 vols). Reykjavík: Hið íslenska bókmenntafélag.Google Scholar
Lucas, G., 2010a. The ceramic revolution in Iceland 1850–1950, in Table Settings: The material culture and social context of dining, AD 1700–1900, ed. Symonds, J.. Oxford: Oxbow, 125–32.Google Scholar
Lucas, G., 2010b. The tensions of modernity: Skálholt in the 17th and 18th centuries. Journal of the North Atlantic, Special Volume 1, 75–88.Google Scholar
Lucas, G., 2012. Later historical archaeology in Iceland. A review. International Journal of Historical Archaeology 16, 437–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lucas, G., 2019. Periodization in archaeology. Starting in the ground, in Time and History in Prehistory, eds Souvatzi, S., Baysal, A. & Baysal, E.. London: Routledge, 77–94.Google Scholar
Lucas, G., 2020. Skál! Drykkjuskapur í Skálholti á 17. og 18. öld, in Minjaþing – helgað Mjöll Snæsdóttir [Cheers! Drinking customs in Skálholt during the 17th and 18th centuries], eds Gísladóttir, G.A., Gestsdóttir, H. & Vésteinsson, O.. Reykjavik: Fornleifastofnun Íslands, 227–44.Google Scholar
Lucas, G. & Jonsson, J.O., forthcoming. Smoke, sniff, chew. Tobacco consumption in Iceland during the 17th–19th centuries, in Archaeologies of Smoking, Pipes and Transatlantic Connections, ed. Hissa, S.. New York (NY): Springer.Google Scholar
MacGregor, N., 2014. A History of the Viking World - in 10 extraordinary objects. Guardian, 3 March 2014. https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2014/mar/03/viking-world-british-museum-neil-macgregor-exhibition (accessed 29 February 2024).Google Scholar
Manuel, M., 2010. Chronology and culture-history in the Indus Valley, in Sirinimal Lakdusinghe Felicitation Volume, eds Gunawardhana, P., Adikari, G., Coningham, R.A.E.. Battaramulla: Neptune, 145–52.Google Scholar
Martin, K., 2022. Uncovering the Archaeology of the Danish Trade Monopoly in Iceland (1602–1787). Merchant Ships and Trade Ports. PhD thesis, University of Iceland.Google Scholar
Maynes, M.J. & Watner, A., 2012. Temporalities and periodization in deep history: technology, gender, and benchmarks of ‘Human Development’. Social Science History 36(1), 59–83.Google Scholar
McGovern, T.H., 2009. Chapter 4: The archaeofauna, in Hofstaðir: Excavations of a Viking Age feasting hall in north-eastern Iceland, ed. Lucas, G.. Reykjavik: Fornleifastofnun Íslands, 168–252.Google Scholar
McGovern, T.H., Vésteinsson, O., Friðriksson, A., et al., 2007. Landscapes of settlement in northern Iceland: historical ecology of human impact & climate fluctuation on the millennial scale. American Anthropologist 109, 27–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Meretoja, H., 2014. Narrative and human existence: ontology, epistemology and ethics. New Literary History 45(1), 89–109.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Milek, K.B., 2012. The roles of pit houses and gendered spaces on Viking-Age farmsteads in Iceland. Medieval Archaeology 56(1), 85–130.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mooney, D.E. & Guðmundsdóttir, L., 2020. Barley cultivation in Viking Age Iceland in light of evidence from Lækjargata 10–12, Reykjavík, in Archaeobotanical Studies of Past Plant Cultivation in Northern Europe, eds Vanhanen, S. & Lagerås, P.. (Advances in Archaeobotany 5.) Eelde: Barkhuis, 5–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morgan, J., 2016. Periodization problems, race and gender in the history of the Early Republic. Journal of the Early Republic 36, 351–7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morgan, L.H., 1877. Ancient Society. London: Macmillan & Co.Google Scholar
Nordahl, E., 1988. Reykjavík from the Archaeological Point of View. (AUN 12.) Uppsala: Societas Archaeologica Uppsaliensis.Google Scholar
O'Brien, M.J. & Lyman, R.L., 2002. Seriation, Stratigraphy and Index Fossils. The backbone of archaeological dating. New York (NY): Springer.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Orser, C., 2013. The politics of periodization, in Reclaiming Archaeology. Beyond the tropes of modernity, ed. González-Ruibal, A.. London: Routledge, 145–54.Google Scholar
Pétursdóttir, Þ., 2009. Icelandic Viking Age graves: lack in material – lack of interpretation? Archaeologia Islandica 7, 22–40.Google Scholar
Renfrew, C., 1978. Before Civilization. Harmondsworth: Penguin.Google Scholar
Roberts, H., 2002. Archaeological Investigations in Aðalstræti 2001. Unpublished interim report. Reykjavik: Fornleifastofnun Íslands.Google Scholar
Róbertsdóttir, H., 2014. Manufacturing in the 18th century. Production, consumption and relative usefulness in Iceland's Old Society. Scandinavian Journal of History 39(1), 49–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Roussell, A., 1953. Byggeskikken paa de nordatlantiske øer [The building tradition of the North Atlantic islands], in Nordisk kultur 17. Byggeskikk/Byggnadskultur [Nordic Culture 17: Building traditions/building cultures], ed. Erixon, E.. Stockholm/Oslo/Copenhagen, 108–32.Google Scholar
Rowley-Conwy, P., 2007. From Genesis to Prehistory. The archaeological Three Age System and its contested reception in Denmark, Britain and Ireland. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sanmark, A., 2004. Power and Conversion. A comparative study of Christianization in Scandinavia. (Occasional Papers in Archaeology 34.) Uppsala: Uppsala University.Google Scholar
Service, E., 1962. Primitive Social Organisation: An evolutionary perspective. New York (NY): Random House.Google Scholar
Shetelig, H., 1937. Islands graver og oldsaker fra vikingetiden [Icelandic graves and antiquities from the Viking Age]. Viking 1, 205–19.Google Scholar
Sigurðardóttir, A., 1966. Híbýlahættir á miðöldum [Housing customs in the Middle Ages]. Reykjavik: Bókaútgáfa menningarsjóðs.Google Scholar
Sigurðsson, I., 2013. Áherzluþættir í fræðsluritum um garðrækt á Íslandi 1765–1900 [Dominant themes in the scholarly literature about cultivation in Iceland 1765-1900]. Vefnir 9, 1–14.Google Scholar
Smith, K.P., 2005. Ore, fire, hammer, sickle: iron production in Viking Age and Early Medieval Iceland, in De Re Metallica: The uses of metal in the Middle Ages, eds Bork, R., Montgomery, S., De Vegvar, C.N., Shortell, E. & Walton, S.A.. (AVISTA Studies in the History of Medieval Technology, Science and Art 4.) Aldershot: Ashgate, 183–206.Google Scholar
Snæsdóttir, M., 1981. Anna á mig. Um snældusnúð frá Stóruborg [Anna owns me. About a spindle whorl from Stóraborg]. Árbók Hins Íslenzka Fornleifafélags 1980, 51–7.Google Scholar
Stefánsson, H., 2019. From Earth. Earth architecture in Iceland. Reykjavik: Gullinsnið.Google Scholar
Strawson, G., 2004. Against narrativity. Ratio 17(4), 428–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tarlow, S., 2009. The Archaeology of Improvement in Britain, 1750–1850. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Vésteinsson, O., 2004. Icelandic farmhouse excavations. Field methods and site choices. Archaeologia Islandica 3, 71–100.Google Scholar
Vésteinsson, O., 2010. On farm-mounds. Archaeologia islandica 8, 13–39.Google Scholar
Vésteinsson, O., 2014. Shopping for identities: Norse and Christian in the Viking Age North Atlantic, in Conversion and Identity in the Viking Age, eds Garipzanov, I. & Bonté, R.. Turnhout: Brepols, 75–91.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vésteinsson, O., 2015. Defining the medieval in Icelandic archaeology, in Medieval Archaeology in Scandinavia and Beyond. History, trends and tomorrow, eds Svart Kristiansen, M., Roesdahl, E. & Graham-Campbell, J.. Aarhus: Aarhus University Press, 213–34.Google Scholar
Vésteinsson, O., 2020. Three burial customs in late 10th century Iceland. Preliminary observations, in Viking Encounters. Proceedings of the Eighteenth Viking Congress, eds Pedersen, A. & Sindbæk, S.. Aarhus: Aarhus University Press, 186–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vésteinsson, O., forthcoming. Small churches in Iceland, in Small Churches and Religious Landscapes in the North Atlantic c. 900–1300, eds Arneborg, J. & Vésteinsson, O.. Turnhout: Brepols.Google Scholar
Vésteinsson, O. & McGovern, T.H., 2012. The peopling of Iceland. Norwegian Archaeological Review 45(2), 206–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vésteinsson, O., Sveinbjörnsdóttir, Á., Gestsdóttir, H., Heinemeier, J. & Friðriksson, A., 2019. Dating religious change. Pagan and Christian in Viking Age Iceland. Journal of Social Archaeology 19(2), 162–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar